All  
Roman dodecahedra

The Enigma of the Roman Dodecahedra

Print

The Roman dodecahedron is a small, hollow object made of bronze or (more rarely) stone, with a geometrical shape that has 12 flat faces. Each face is a pentagon, a five-sided shape. The Roman dodecahedra are also embellished with a series of knobs on each corner point of the pentagons, and the pentagon faces in most cases contain circular holes in them. More than 200 years after they were first discovered, researchers are no closer to understanding the origin and function of this mysterious object .

Roman dodecahedra date from the 2nd or 3rd centuries AD, and typically range from 4cm to 11cm (1.57-4.33 inches) in size. To date, more than one hundred of these artifacts have been found across Great Britain, Belgium, Germany, France, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Austria, Switzerland, and Hungary.

An incomplete cast copper alloy dodecahedron

An incomplete cast copper alloy dodecahedron (1 – 400 AD), discovered by a metal detectorist in Yorkshire,  England. ( Portable Antiquities Scheme /CC BY SA )

What were Roman Dodecahedra Used for?

The great mystery is: how do they work and what do they do? Unfortunately, there is no documentation or notes about them from the time of their creation, so the function of the dodecahedra has not been determined. Nevertheless, many theories and speculations have been put forward over the centuries: candlestick holders (wax was found inside one example), dice, survey instruments, devices for determining the optimal sowing date for winter grain, gauges to calibrate water pipes or standard army bases, staff or scepter decorations, a toy to throw and catch on a stick, or simply a geometric sculpture . Among these speculations, some deserve attention.

A popular hypothesis these days for the purpose of the dodecahedra is that they were used as knitting tools to make gloves. Whether it solves the mystery or not, the YouTube video by Martin Hallett, who tested his idea with a 3D printed replica of a Roman dodecahedron and some experimental archaeology, has inspired others to try out this knitting method to make their own hand warmers. This idea could explain the different sizes of the dodecahedra – making gloves of different sizes - and the purpose of the holes – to form the glove’s fingers.

However, one of the most accepted theories is that the Roman dodecahedron was used as a measuring device, more precisely as a range measuring object on the battlefield. The hypothesis is that the dodecahedron was used for calculating the trajectories of projectiles. This could explain the different sized holes in the pentagrams.

A similar theory involves dodecahedra as a surveying and levelling device. However, neither of these theories has been supported by any proof and exactly how the dodecahedron could be used for these purposes has not been fully explained.

Dodecahedron from the region of Stuttgart; 2nd to 3rd Century, shown at the Württembergisches Landesmuseum, Stuttgart, Germany; Approximately 60 such dodecahedra from this region and time are known, however their function is not clear. (Anagoria/ CC BY 3.0 )

Or Maybe they were Astronomical Tools, Religious Relics or Toys?

One of the more interesting theories is the proposal that dodecahedra were astronomic measuring instruments for determining the optimal sowing date for winter grain. According to G.M.C. Wagemans , "the dodecahedron was an astronomic measuring instrument with which the angle of the sunlight can be measured and thereby one specific date in springtime, and one date in the autumn can be determined with accuracy. The dates that can be measured were probably of importance for the agriculture".

Nevertheless, opponents of this theory have pointed out that use as a measuring instrument of any kind seems to be prohibited by the fact that the dodecahedra were not standardized and come in many sizes and arrangements.

A Roman dodecahedron found in Bonn, Germany

A Roman dodecahedron found in Bonn, Germany. ( Hadley Paul Garland/ CC BY SA 2.0 )

Another unproven theory claims that the dodecahedra are religious relics, once used as sacred tools for the druids of Britannia and Caledonia. However, there is no written account or archaeological evidence to support this view. Could it be that this strange item was simply a toy or a recreational game for legionnaires, during the war campaigns?

Some sources suggest they were the central objects in a bowl game similar to that of our days, with these artifacts used as markers and the players throwing stones to land them in the holes within the dodecahedra.

Two ancient Roman bronze dodecahedrons and an icosahedron (3rd c. AD) in the Rheinisches Landesmuseum in Bonn, Germany. The dodecahedrons were excavated in Bonn and Frechen-Bachem; the icosahedron in Arloff. ( CC BY SA 4.0 )

A Roman Icosahedron Adds to the Mystery

Another discovery deepens the mystery about the function of these objects. Some time ago, Benno Artmann discovered a Roman icosahedron (a polyhedron with 20 faces), misclassified as a dodecahedron on just a superficial glance, and put away in a museum's basement storage. The discovery raises the question about whether there are many other geometric artifacts of different types – such as, icosahedra, hexagons, octagons – yet to be found in what was once the significant Roman Empire.

The Roman icosahedron found by Benno Artmann

The Roman icosahedron found by Benno Artmann. ( georgehart.com)

Despite the many unanswered questions, one thing is certain, the Roman dodecahedra were highly valued by their owners. This is evidenced by the fact that a number of them were found among treasure hoards , with coins and other valuable items.  We may never know the true purpose of the Roman dodecahedra, but we can only hope that advances in archaeology will unearth more clues that will help solve this ancient enigma.

Top Image: A Roman dodecahedron. Source: BigStockPhoto

By Federico Cataldo

References

The Roman dodecahedron – Legends and Chronicles. Available from: http://www.legendsandchronicles.com/ancient-artifacts/the-roman-dodecahedrons/

Roman dodecahedra – George Hard. Available from: http://www.georgehart.com/virtual-polyhedra/roman_dodecahedra.html

Has The Roman Dodecahedron Mystery Been Solved? – Red Ice Creations. Available from: http://redicecreations.com/article.php?id=30435

Has The Roman Dodecahedron Mystery Been Solved? – Gralien Report. Available from:
http://www.gralienreport.com/ancient-mysteries-2/man-solved-roman-dodecahedron-mystery/

The Roman Pentagon Dodecahedron: An Astronomic Measuring Instrument for Determining the Optimal Sowing Date for Winter Grain – By G.M.C. Wagemans. Available from: http://www.romandodecahedron.com/the-hypothesis

Comments

But i dont see why have all the stems on them then.. they serve no purpose during flight or for Any type crash landing. and made from brass, they would not hold their shape after crashing into stone.

How about being used as pitch balls. You stuff them with cotton dip in oil or pitch, load large quantities of these in catapults, light on Fire and let fly.

Future generations will find our Rubiks Cubes and ask the exact same questions.

Pretty obviously used for holding various cords together at exact angles (hence the spheres to prevent slipping) without the use of knots

I notice that the balls on the icosahedra are different size, while it's the holes on the dodecahedra which are different size. I'm wondering if some sort of puzzle might be possible where you interlock some pieces around another, having to get the right sized hole to the right sized ball.

I don't know off the top of my head if the geometry works for that. However, the icosahedron and dodecahedron are "duals" of each other. If you connect all of the center points from the faces of either polyhedron, you'll get the other polyhedron nestled inside it.

That means there should be several different possible ways the two could fit together.

Also, I'm curious if the icosahedron is solid, as there should be many more surviving examples of that shape if solid. However, the opposite is true if the shape is hollow, given the odd sized balls at the vertexes.

aHEMagain

Pages

Next article