All  
Neanderthal flute

Study dismisses remarkable Neanderthal flute as the work of hyenas

The Divje Babe flute, discovered in a cave in Slovenia in 1995, has long been heralded as the oldest musical instrument ever discovered.  The item is a fragment of the femur of a cave bear which had been pierced with evenly-spaced and perfectly-formed holes, dated to between 60,000-43,000 years old. The age of the relic radically suggested that Neanderthals were crafting flutes prior to the emergence of Homo sapiens in the region. For some scientists, this conclusion was just too much to swallow. A new study claims the ancient artifact is nothing more than a bone that had been chewed on by hyenas.

The Divje Babe archaeological site is located in a cave 230m above the Idrijca River, near Cerkno. Researchers working at this site have uncovered more than 600 archaeological finds in at least ten levels, including 20 hearths with evidence of habitation by Neanderthals about 55,000 years ago. They have also found the skeletal remains of numerous cave bears.

Excavation in the cave Divje Babe I, where the Neanderthal flute was found

Excavation in the cave Divje Babe I, where the Neanderthal flute was found ( Wikipedia)

In 2008, another discovery was made – a bone flute in the Hohle Fels cave near Ulm in Germany dating back 43,000 years.  The five-holed flute has a V-shaped mouthpiece and is made from a vulture wing bone.  It was one of several similar instruments found in the area, with others dating back to 35,000 years ago and made from mammoth ivory.  The mammoth-ivory flutes would have been especially challenging to make. Using only stone tools, the flute maker would have had to split a section of curved ivory along its natural grain. The two halves would then have been hollowed out, carved, and fitted together with an airtight seal.

Scientists say this bone flute found in the Hohle Fels cave dates back around 43,000 years.

Scientists say this bone flute found in the Hohle Fels cave dates back around 43,000 years. Credit: Jensen / University of Tubingen

The cave in southern Germany contains early evidence for the occupation of early Homo sapiens and on announcing the discovery, scientists suggested that the "finds demonstrate the presence of a well-established musical tradition at the time when modern humans colonized Europe".  In the academic field, a flute made by early humans was much easier to accept than a flute made by Neanderthals, who had long been viewed as inferior to Homo sapiens and nothing more than subhuman brutes – a view that is now largely dismissed.

MORE

Nevertheless, there still remains a minority of scientists who do not accept the possibility that Neanderthals were playing music and have claimed instead that the perfectly spaced and neatly carved holes are in fact the result of the bone fragment having been chewed on by an animal – a little hard to believe after watching this video showing the music produced by the reconstructed flute. 

In a paper published in the Royal Society of Open Science , Dr Cajus Diedrich from the Paleo-Logic Independent Institute of Geosciences took a look at several musical instruments that had been attributed to Neanderthals. Dr Diedrich said analysis of the bone shows the holes are teeth marks, and the shape is just the result of the bone not breaking when it was chewed.

“The research suggests historians have been fooled by these phoney objects - and, in fact, all such ‘instruments’ attributed to Neanderthals are simply chew toys of animals,” reports the Mail Online .

“Hyenas left bones in repeating similar tooth mark and crush damage stages, demonstrating a butchering/bone cracking strategy,” Dr Diedrich wrote. “Hyenas produced round-oval puncture marks in cub femora only by the bone-crushing premolar teeth of both upper and lower jaw.”

Dr Diedrich had dismissed all the research that has been conducted on flute bones so far. However, in recent years the consensus that the Divje Babe flute is an authentic musical instrument has been growing as the view of Neanderthals has changed from subhuman brutes to more sophisticated humans.

Featured image: The Divje Babe flute displayed in the National Museum of Slovenia  in Ljubljana. Credit: BoBo]

By April Holloway

Comments

jorgan's picture

Experts are, so often, to much of it – like superexperts with almost supernatural insights in things. but when, like in the case of  the new study seeing incredible things, claiming that the ancient artifact (remarkable Neanderthal flute is just “work of the hyenas”) exactly bone with holes has nothing to do with flute for reason being nothing more than a bone “chewed on by hyenas”.
 I always had great deal of repect even admiration, for scientific work and mind despite the fact that mistakes had happen, or not so good intentions emerged now and then (who ever lived under communist regime quickly lear thet science so easy become propaganda and deadly tool in the politics). This particular study results smells on such a past time scenarios. Even if is not a musical instrument, hyenas story is way too much to swallow.

 

goran

           

This so-called "Royal Society of Open Science" sounds like a bogus scientific group whose members have been discredited for sloppy practices and wacky ideas. The sad thing about the internet these days is that anyone who can code a page can gain followers and legitimacy. And if more than a dozen can look as if they have credentials and make their beliefs seem to hold water, then they will gain exposure in the media.

If these holes were the result of hyenas, they would not be that regularly spaced nor would they be of the same size. Animal teeth are not arranged in straight lines and they are generally different sizes.

And the edges of the holes would be splintered, not smooth without cracks. Even fresh bones splinter when enough pressure is applied as anyone who has had a "greenstick" fracture can attest. The vulture bone flute even has countersunk holes and the only way countersunk holes can be made by hyenas is if they had drills.

Then again, I guess this scientist suspects that ancient hyenas had hand drills and used them.

Sorry, but a bit of common sense goes a long way to prevent gullibility.

nisa burkay's picture

i would not think hyenas teeth to be so perfectly round would anyone else? Frrom the images I see online they are more oval in shape.

 

Nisa Carroll Burkay

Another attempt to discredit our ancient ancestors. These people are clearly politically motivated in their ''studies''. It makes me sick. Probably just a bunch of ignorant Christians, like usual....

This so-called science isn't Christian.

Pages

Register to become part of our active community, get updates, receive a monthly newsletter, and enjoy the benefits and rewards of our member point system OR just post your comment below as a Guest.

Next article