All  
Main: The Tel Motza Iron Age temple excavation site in Jerusalem.    Source: Skyview / Israel Antiquities Authority.     Inset: Ancient figurines of people found at Tel Motza.        Source: Clara Amit / Israel Antiquities Authority

Iron Age Temple Uncovered in Jerusalem Challenges Biblical Claim

Print

The famous Temple of Solomon might not have been the first or only temple in the Holy Land.

Dating to around 900 BC, an Iron Age temple located near Jerusalem negates the long-held idea the ancient Kingdom of Judah (southern Israel) only had one temple, the First Temple, better known as Solomon's Temple, which was operational between 10th century BC until it was destroyed in 586 BC.

The Iron Age site of Tel Motza, about 4 miles (6.4 kilometers) outside Jerusalem, has been known of since the early 1990s and archaeologists found the remains of a settlement dated to the Neolithic period (about 6000 BC). In 2012 a settlement from the First Temple period was discovered containing a cultic structure and 36 wheat granaries, indicating that Motza was part of an ancient economic center, and it is the presence of this one ancient religious complex that challenges the history of Judah presented in the Bible.

The Tel Motza Iron Age temple excavation site in Jerusalem. (Natritmeyer / CC BY-SA 4.0)

The Tel Motza Iron Age temple excavation site in Jerusalem. (Natritmeyer / CC BY-SA 4.0 )

Judah Was Not As Well Established As The Bible States

A new study of the temple by co-researcher Shua Kisilevitz, a doctoral student of archaeology at Tel Aviv University in Israel and an archaeologist with the Israel Antiquities Authority (IAA), and review co-author Oded Lipschits, the director of the Sonia and Marco Nadler Institute of Archaeology at Tel Aviv University, was published in the January/February issue of the  Biblical Archaeology Review  magazine. In the article the researchers say the temple had been built about 900 BC and that they think it operated until the early 6th century BC.

And where this discovery is controversial is that the existence of this temple means that people living close to Jerusalem had their own place of worship, a cultic temple, which in itself suggests the rule of the Jerusalem high priests was “not so strong”, and that the kingdom was “not so well established” as the Bible leads us to believe, Kisilevitz and Lipschits, told Live Science .

Oldest Known Horse Depictions In Judah

A report in the Daily Mail detailing the study says the ancient temple could have held about 150 congregants who worshiped the god Yahweh, but they also used idols to communicate with the divine in the same period as the First Temple. This contradicts the Jewish Bible that details the religious reforms of  King Hezekiah  and King Josiah, who consolidated worship at Solomon's Temple in Jerusalem, and allegedly stopped ‘all’ cultic practices out of its walls.

Kisilevitz told Live Science that the temple was a rectangular building with an open courtyard at the front that would have been a focal point for cultic worship, and inside they found a stone built sacrificial altar near pits for dead animal bodies. Two human-like and two horse-like clay figurines were discovered smashed and buried in the courtyard, which was thought to have been associated with a rainfall, fertility and harvest ritual of some kind. The researchers added that the horse-like figurines may be the “oldest known depictions of  horses from the Iron Age of Judah.”

Figurine of a horse found in Tel Motza Iron Age temple in excavation site. (Clara Amit / Israel Antiquities Authority)

Figurine of a horse found in Tel Motza Iron Age temple in excavation site. (Clara Amit / Israel Antiquities Authority )

Smashed Idols, Broken History

The teams of archaeologists at Tel Motza unearthed dozens of grain storage silos (granaries) and associated administrative and religious buildings. This informs us that Tel Motza sold grain to the nearby Jerusalem. Over time, the settlement is believed to have become an agricultural and economic “powerhouse,” the researchers wrote in the magazine piece. They also speculate that perhaps the temple was permitted to exist by the high priests at Solomon’s Temple, because it was part of the granary and didn’t threaten centralized control of the kingdom.

During the time this temple was functional, new political groups and alliances emerged in the Levant, and it is believed that in the face of these changes people maintained traditional religious practices. The researchers said this was evident in the temple’s artifacts and architecture, which they say are reminiscent of religious traditions from the ancient Near East that had been practiced since the third millennium BC.

Figurine of a ram found in Tel Motza Iron Age temple excavation site. (Yael Yolovitch / Israel Antiquities Authority)

Figurine of a ram found in Tel Motza Iron Age temple excavation site. (Yael Yolovitch / Israel Antiquities Authority )

The discovery and analysis of this ancient Iron Age temple not only enlightens historians on the state formation of Judah during this period. It also determines that the state was nowhere near as centralized as it would later become and that in its formative days it depended not solely on the administrative elite at Solomon’s Temple, but on trading relationships with nearby settlements like Tel Motza, and maybe others yet to be discovered.

Top image: Main: The Tel Motza Iron Age temple excavation site in Jerusalem.    Source: Skyview / Israel Antiquities Authority .     Inset: Ancient figurines of people found at Tel Motza.        Source: Clara Amit / Israel Antiquities Authority

By Ashley Cowie

Comments

Biblo-centric asumption archaeology is So exasperating, It is as though someone is writing an article about discovering the Taj Mahal and making great note of the fact that it must have existed at the same time as the black Taj. Isnt that amazing?!

Its the same thing- There is not a single artifact that has ever come out of the ground denoting Solomon. Not a single stone of the 1st Temple has ever been found. There is no mention of the temple or Solomon or any Judahite king with the slightest wealth or importance in the 8th century ‘by the next door Egyptians, the Assyrians, or the Phonecians but when a significant multi hectare temple complex is found next door to Jerusalem- isnt that amazing that it existed at the same time as the 1st temple? The 1st temple was not the only temple in town? 

No kidding. Anyone with a molecule of scientific logic in their brain would conclude that in all liklihood Aliens did not beam Solomon and his temple to the Klingon planet Kronos and Tel Motza was the only temple in town.  Now that! is interesting.

Philip Olson's picture

Food sources are important and keeping food coming in at a steady pace was even more important before refrigeration.

The town that produced the food worshipped in their own temple in their own town.  Wisdom says this is fine if the alternatives have questionable reliability and higher prices.

When the empire grew larger with choices of vendors for food the city state became unionized and replaced the non union employees throughout the land.  If this one party rule had been tried too soon the kingdom’s slower growth would have led to more outside interference.

Old societies are my hobby.  The transition periods and how they are conducted keep it fascinating.

Speed of dark

Jerusalem was considered to be a holy place long before the Jews got there.  It probably relates to a temple considered to be built by Enoch.

 

Mike

Paul Davies's picture

Firstly, this author obviously hasn’t READ the Old Testament. Pretty much the WHOLE narrative is about how the Hebrews “prostituted” themsleves with other gods, then suffered judgment, eventually repented, and “cleansed the land”, then repeat….

Secondly, the dating techniques are ALL dodgy – there are now years of paperssaying the assumptions are incorrect and not repeatable. Unfortunately, archaeologists don’t listen to the Science…. (unfortunately, neither do the scientists...)

Thirdly, the standard of validity in History/Archaeology is RUBBISH, even accepting the idiocy going on in the science camp at the moment. Most of what they say is GUESSING, with little actual valid supporting evidence.

 

PauLD

Next article