What Really Happened to Valerian? Was the Roman Emperor Humiliated and Skinned at the Hands of the Enemy?
The death of Valerian is traditionally known as one of the most dramatic and unfortunate of all the deaths of the Roman emperors. The widely accepted story is that Valerian wanted to end the war with the Sassanians by offering them money. The Sassanian king, Shapur I sent the ambassadors back to Valerian with a message that he wanted the emperor to come and appeal to him in person. When Valerian went to Shapur with a small retinue, he was seized by the Sassanians. According to Byzantine historian Zosimus, Valerian ended his days in the capacity of a slave among the Persians.
Shahnameh illustration of Valerian captured by Shapur I's men. ( Public Domain )
Lactantius’ account of Valerian’s fate is more gruesome. Lactantius, ancient Christian author and advisor to Constantine I, claimed that Emperor Valerian was used as a human footstool whenever Shapur wanted to mount his horse. After Valerian’s death, Lactantius claims that “he was flayed, and his skin, stripped from the flesh, was dyed with vermilion, and placed in the temple of the gods of the barbarians.”
The Humiliation of the Emperor Valerian by the Persian King Shapur, 1521. ( Public Domain )
However, inscriptions and rock-reliefs commemorating Shapur’s victories from the Persian side do not support these claims. A damaged scene at Bishapur shows Shapur on horseback with Roman Emperor Gordian III under his horse and another Roman Emperor Phillip kneeling before him.
Shapur’s Triumph over Valerian in Bishapur. (Sahand Ace/ CC BY-SA 3.0 )
A nearby rock-relief represents Shapur on horseback at the center of a prostrating Gordian and Valerian standing at the side of the king who holds him by wrist. Another carving at Naqs-e Rostam shows a kneeling Philip and a standing Valerian. Finally, a Roman-Persian workmanship depicts Shapur and Valerian in hand-to-hand combat. All representations of the captive Valerian show him as unfettered and in regalia, disproving the rumors that he was mistreated. So why did the Roman writers claim otherwise?
Cameo of Shapur I and Emperor Valerianus, 260 AD. (Marie-Lan Nguyen / CC BY 2.5 )
Conflicting Accounts of Shapur’s Triumphs - Did Shapur Achieve His Victories Fairly?
Despite differing accounts between the Sassanians and the Romans, the Persian inscriptions and rock-reliefs agree with Roman sources that there were three campaigns between the Romans and the Sassanians. The Roman account, given in the official biography of Gordian, is that Gordian set out against the Persians in 242 CE with a huge army and great quantity of gold.
Bust of Gordianus III/Gorian. Marble, Roman artwork, between 242 and 244 AD. From Gabii. (Jastrow/ CC BY 2.5 )
They then spent the winter in Antioch where he drove Shapur out from Antioch, Carrhae and Nisibis, routed him at Resaina (modern Ra’s al-’Ain) and forced him to restore all occupied cities, unharmed, to their citizens. However, Philip the Arab, prefect of the guard at the time, convinced the soldiers to proclaim him joint emperor and hastily retreated towards the Roman frontier during which Gordian perished. Accounts of Gordian’s death varied. Eusebius of Caesarea believed that Gordian was killed in Parthia, Zosimus relates that Gordian was killed in enemy’s land, and a Joannes Zonaras reports that the emperor was overthrown from his horse in a battle, broke his thigh, and died of his wound. All accounts say that Philip then swore friendship and made “a most shameful treaty” with Shapur to end the war.
The Persian view, given by Shapur himself, says that Gordian marched on Asurestan (Assyria), against the Sassanians, culminating in a battle at Misike where Giordanus was killed and the Sassanians defeated the Roman army. The Romans then proclaimed Philip emperor, who proceeded to pay 500,000 denars to Shapur as ransom for his life. Having removed the Roman threat and enriched his treasury, Shapur brought the Roman protectorate of western Armenia under Persian control.
This FREE PREVIEW is just a taste of the great benefits you can find at Ancient Origins Premium.
- The Strategic Use of Hostages in the Ancient World
- The Colossal Statue of Shapur, Powerful King of the Sassanian Empire
- The Truth About Lie Detection in Ancient and Modern Times
- The Battle of Carrhae: A crushing defeat of the unstoppable Roman juggernaut by the Parthian Empire