104,000-Year-Old Tooth of Mysterious Hominin Child Raises Questions About Human Evolution
By Debbie Guatelli-Steinberg / Science Advances
A relative of modern humans that lived at least 104,000 years ago in northern China showed evidence of dental growth and development very similar to that of people today, a new study found.
An international team of scientists performed the first systematic assessment of dental growth and development in an East Asian archaic hominin fossil that is known as the Xujiayao juvenile. The fossil is of a 6 1/2-year-old who lived between 104,000 and 248,000 years ago found at the Xujiayao site in northern China. The researchers were surprised to find that in most ways, this child's dental development was very similar to what you would find in a child today, said Debbie Guatelli-Steinberg, co-author of the study and professor of anthropology at The Ohio State University.
Dental remains of the Xujiayao juvenile. (S.X. /Institute of Vertebrate Paleontology and Paleoanthropology, Chinese Academy of Sciences. / OSU)
Archaic Human Fossil Found in East Asia
"The Xujiayao juvenile is the oldest fossil found in east Asia that has dental development comparable to modern humans," Guatelli-Steinberg said. "It may suggest that these archaic humans had a slow life history like modern humans, with a prolonged period of childhood dependency."
What Does the Fossil Tell Us?
Teeth provide some of the best data anthropologists have about the growth and development of our ancient ancestors, she said. That's because growth lines in teeth retain a record of dental development.
Compared to our primate cousins, modern humans - including their teeth - take a long time to form and develop. Anthropologists believe this characteristic is associated with humans' longer periods of child dependency - how long a juvenile relies on support from a caregiver.
Growth lines found on digitally reconstructed teeth show a development similar to a modern child. ( S. Xing and Paul Tafforeau )
What Techniques Were Used to Study the Fossil?
Among other techniques, the researchers used synchrotron X-ray imaging to look inside the fossil to see the internal structure of the teeth, including growth lines that revealed the rate of tooth development.
Left image is a sinogram which is a graphic representation of the raw data obtained from a CT scan. At right is an image sample derived from the raw data. (Kyungtaek Jun & Seokhwan Yoon / CC BY-SA 2.5 )
The results were surprising in part because so many other features of this hominin are not modern, such as the shape and thickness of the skull and the large size of the teeth, according to the researchers.
"We don't know exactly where this enigmatic East Asian hominin fits in human evolution," said Song Xing, lead author of the study, who is at the Chinese Academy of Sciences in Beijing.
"It has some affinities to archaic human relatives like the Denisovans and Neanderthals with, as we found, some more modern features. It is a strange mosaic."
Dental remains of the Xujiayao juvenile. Original Xujiayao fossil (A and C) and μCT reconstruction of all the teeth (B and D). M 1 and a part of the root of the deciduous dm 2 are visible in the superior view photo, as is the M 2 crown. I 1 and C were removed from their sockets and appear in the picture as isolated teeth. Note that P 3, P 4, and M 2 were still unerupted. (A and B) Inferior view. (C and D) Superior view. (A and C) Photographed by S.X. from Institute of Vertebrate Paleontology and Paleoanthropology, Chinese Academy of Sciences. (Debbie Guatelli-Steinberg / OSU)
Results Show Juvenile Was Growing Normally
Using the growth lines in the teeth, the researchers estimated the death of the Xujiayao juvenile at about 6 1/2 years of age, said study co-author Mackie O'Hara, a graduate student in anthropology at Ohio State.
The first molar of this juvenile -- what we call the 6-year-molar today -- had erupted a few months before death and had started to wear a bit. The root was about three-quarters complete, similar to humans today.
"We found that this juvenile was growing up - at least dentally - according to a schedule similar to that of modern people," O'Hara said.
Developmental chart of the Xujiayao permanent teeth. The vertical lines were dashed when the stress lines have not been detected in that portion of the tooth. MB, mesiobuccal cusp. (Debbie Guatelli-Steinberg / OSU)
Study Shows the Fossil Has Characteristics of Modern Humans
Another aspect that was similar to modern humans was the perikymata, which are the incremental growth lines that appear on the surface of the tooth.
"We found that the way these perikymata were distributed on the Xujiayao juvenile teeth was close to what we see in modern humans, and not to Neanderthals," Guatelli-Steinberg said.
Another interesting finding related to the long-period growth line, which is laid down about every eight days in modern humans.
"This juvenile had a 10-day rhythm, which you don't see very often in early hominins," she said. "Most of the early hominins had a shorter rhythm, closer to seven days. This is another aspect that is much more modern."
Some Uncharacteristic Results Discovered
The one aspect of dental development in the Xujiayao juvenile that was not modern was the rate of growth in the roots of the teeth. Here, the juvenile showed relatively fast growth, compared to a slower growth in modern humans.
While the dental development of this juvenile suggested it had a slow life course similar to modern humans, Guatelli-Steinberg cautioned that we don't know what happens in later childhood in hominins like this one.
"It would be interesting to see if dental development in later childhood, such as the growth and development of third molars, was also similar to modern humans," she said.
- Archaeologists Find Medieval Dentures Made from the Teeth of Dead People
- New Studies Clash with Previous Analyses On the Life and Fate of Neanderthals
- Oldest Human DNA Reveals Mysterious Branch of Humanity
Hominini/Homininae phylogeny, 10 Mya to present. (Dbachmann / CC BY-SA 4.0 )
Top image: Study finds an archaic hominin had modern dental growth.(Inset: Two digitally reconstructed teeth) Source: EmotionPhoto / Adobe Stock (Inset: S. Xing and Paul Tafforeau )
The article, originally titled ‘ An ancient relative of humans shows a surprisingly modern trait: Study finds an archaic hominin had modern dental growth." was originally published on Science Daily.
Source: Ohio State University. " An ancient relative of humans shows a surprisingly modern trait: Study finds an archaic hominin had modern dental growth. ”ScienceDaily. ScienceDaily, 16 January 2019.
Song Xing et al. First systematic assessment of dental growth and development in an archaic hominin (genus, Homo) from East Asia . Science Advances , 2019 DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.aau0930
Thank you for this article; I find the topic fascinating and therefore of great interest to my own efforts. It really does seem that the more we discover, the more questions we must ask...and the more knowledge we must seek. Again, thank you.
Sanjay R Singhal, RA
So with all this evidence, where does Darwin fit in? Actually, here's so much evidence against Darwinism why keep the show going?
White Snake 29
It seems that new discoveries in the homo line are popping up frequently. The landscape is littered with failed experiments of evolution or possibly manipulation, whether by nature or by some external agent. Whether it’s God, the gods, or ancient astronauts is not as important to me as the implications for the future of Homo Sapiens – some believe that we may be approaching the ‘singularity’, melding of man with machines, or does AI take over totally?
You know nothing Jon Snow...I mean Charles Ford. Take your creationist fairy-tales and gtfoh
Problem is the article declines to stop with dogma, The tooth is not 104,000 years old. That is a red herring. What we do know is it is a modern tooth and that it belonged to a child. That it fits a modern tooth supports the six thousand yer old creation model and further detsrys the falsity of billiuons of years and molecules to man.