All  
The Starving of Saqqara sculpture.

Elongated Skulls and Indecipherable Language: What Does the Mysterious Starving of Saqqara Sculpture Mean?

Print

The Starving of Saqqara is the name given to an ancient Egyptian sculpture believed to date to the Pre-Dynastic period. Little is known about the origins and provenance of this statue, which is today held by Montreal’s Concordia University. Additionally, it is unclear as to the subject matter of the sculpture, and there has been debate about the artifact’s authenticity as well.

The Starving of Saqqara is a limestone sculpture measuring at 67 cm (26 inches), and weighing about 80 kg (176.37 lbs). The statue was carved from limestone, and depicts a pair of nude seated figures. One of the figures is a male and the other is often assumed to be a female holding a child. The figures are notable for their elongated heads , and thin, elongated limbs. Traces of pigments on the statue suggest that it was once painted. Furthermore, there are some ancient inscriptions carved onto the base of the statue, though its language hasn’t been identified yet.

Three views of the Starving of Saqqara. (Concordia University/ YouTube Screenshot )

The Sculpture’s Modern History

The modern history of the Starving of Saqqara began during the 20th century. The statue came into the possession of Vincent and Olga Diniacopoulos, who were avid collectors of ancient Egyptian, Greek, and Roman antiquities, prior to the 1950s. It is unclear how and where the Diniacopoulos family acquired the statue. Moreover, in spite of its name, the relationship between the statue and Saqqara, the vast burial ground outside the ancient Egyptian capital of Memphis, is unknown.

Vincent and Olga Diniacopoulos immigrated to Montreal from France, and the Starving of Saqqara was one of the artifacts they took with them on their journey. During the 1950s, the sculpture was displayed in the family-owned Galerie Ars Classica. After Vincent Diniacopoulos’ death in 1967, much of the collection was packed by the family and stored in the basement of their house. The Starving of Saqqara was part of this collection, and remained hidden for the next few decades.

In 1999, Olga Diniacopoulos requested Concordia University to assist with the management of the family’s antiquities collection. Part of the funds was to be used for student scholarships at the university, where Olga’s son, Denis, was a faculty member. The man responsible for this undertaking was Clarence Epstein, who, whilst studying the collection, brought the Starving of Saqqara back into the light. At that point of time, the statue was in fragments.

Making Sense of the Starving of Saqqara

After re-assembling the sculpture, the next step was to make sense of it. As the Diniacopoulos family themselves were uncertain about the statue’s origins and history, researchers from around the world were contacted. Experts from such institutes as the British Museum, the University of Cambridge, and the Israel Museum were contacted, in the hopes that the sculpture might be identified. Unfortunately, no one was able to say what it was with certainty.

The Starving of Saqqara is generally thought to date to the Pre-Dynastic period . Epstein further states that the sculpture may have been from a tomb or burial site, and that it was meant to represent the people that were conquered by an ancient Egyptian ruler. The physical features of the sculpted figures suggest that they may have been meant to represent Nubians. Others, however, have suggested that the sculpture may have been created around the time when the Jews were exiled from Egypt. Some have even considered that the sculpture might be a modern fake.

Nubian features on the Starving of Saqqara sculpture. (Concordia University/YouTube Screenshot)

Nubian features on the Starving of Saqqara sculpture. (Concordia University/ YouTube Screenshot )

The authenticity of the Starving of Saqqara has been questioned due to the fact that the experts are unaware of anything else like it. Nevertheless, it is generally held that the sculpture is real. Experts at Concordia University, for instance, point out that the sculpture had been legally authorized for export. Considering that this was done during a period when the trade in antiquities was casual and poorly monitored, they argue that the sculpture is genuine. Another expert, the Swiss art historian Jean-Jacques Fiechter, wrote that the sculpture had to be genuine, otherwise Vincent Diniacopoulos, an experienced collector, would not have bought it, and then shipped it all the way to Montreal at a heavy cost.

Still, one may argue that even experts make mistakes. In any case, the sculpture remains a mystery, and further research has been considered by Concordia University.

Top image: The Starving of Saqqara sculpture. Source: Ritual Abuse Investigations

By Wu Mingren

References

Boswell, R., 2011. Canadian university puts ancient, mysterious sculpture on display. Available at: https://www.sott.net/article/225917-Canadian-university-puts-ancient-mysterious-sculpture-on-display

Concordia University, 2019. CSI Montreal: Concordia Sculpture Investigation. Available at: http://www.concordia.ca/arts/diniacopoulos/egyptian-antiquities/sculpture-investigation.html

CTV.ca News Staff, 2011. Unravelling the mystery of an ancient statue. Available at: https://www.ctvnews.ca/unravelling-the-mystery-of-an-ancient-statue-1.620710

Curran, P., 2011. Mysterious Art. Available at: https://www.pressreader.com/canada/montreal-gazette/20110317/289167264389133

Current World Archaeology, 2011. Egyptian Enigma: The Starving of Saqqara. Available at: https://www.world-archaeology.com/features/egyptian-enigma-the-starving-of-saqqara/

Comments

The fact that this thing is made of a soft stone, seems to me makes it more likely to be a modern forgery than an ancient piece – nobody is going to carve a fake from very hard granite, but they would easily carve something from soft limestone. It looks to me like something with an African flair – rather like the Ethiopean or Sudanese carvings. The longish face & nose may be simply because it was considered a desirous look rather than what was normal all around them – a lot of African stuff doesn’t look like the people’s that produced it.  I have several things my ex-husband carved in wood, that if/when they find them one day might completely lead an archaeologist up the creek !  Art is art, doesn’t have to match anything since it comes from the creators mind !  Then the language they have not deciphered – equally strange !  

Has anybody looked into the giants of the ABC Islands ( Aruba, Bonaire and Curacao ) ? The islands were formerly called Los Islas de Los Gigantes by the Spanish explorers. Supposedly there a giant museum on Aruba.

Was unaware "nubians" had aquiline noses..looks like these figures contain features from every race of humanity combined in to one..wonder if this is current humanity's ancestor.

Next article