Despite Intensive Scientific Analyses, Parthenon Marble Stain Remains a Mystery

For almost 200 years, archaeologists have been puzzled by a mysterious brown stain on the ancient Greek Parthenon temple in Greece. Now, researchers have conducted new scientific analyses, and their verdict is clear: The mystery remains.

At the National Museum in Copenhagen, Denmark, there is a marble head that was once part of the ancient Greek Parthenon temple on the Acropolis in Athens. The head originally belonged to a centaur figure and was part of a scene depicting the Greek mythological Lapiths' battle against the centaurs (mythical creatures that were half-horse, half-human).

For reasons that have yet to be explained, parts of the centaur head are coated with a thin brown film, as are several other marble fragments from the Parthenon.

Pondering the Dubious Brown Substance

The mysterious brown film was first examined by the British Museum in 1830.

Back then, attempts were made to determine if the color originated from ancient paint, but it was eventually concluded that it might be a result of a chemical reaction between the marble and the air, or that the marble contained iron particles that had migrated to the surface, coloring it brown.

• The Mentor Shipwreck and the Disastrous Journey of the Parthenon Marbles to Britain
• Ancient Greek Science and Technology – From Antikythera to Pharos

 

 

The Centaur head at the National Museum in Copenhagen, front view. (Courtesy of The National Museum of Denmark/Heritage Science Journal)

Oxalic Acid, Algae and Fungi

"There have been many attempts to explain the peculiar brown film. In 1851, German chemist, Justus von Liebig, performed the first actual scientific investigation and determined that the brown film contained oxalates -- salts of oxalic acid. This has been confirmed by later analyses, but the origin of the oxalates has remained a mystery," says Professor emeritus Kaare Lund Rasmussen, an expert in chemical analyses of historical and archaeological artifacts, Department of Physics, Chemistry and Pharmacy, University of Southern Denmark.

Along with University of Southern Denmark colleagues Frank Kjeldsen and Vladimir Gorshkov from the Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Bodil Bundgaard Rasmussen, former head of the Antiquities Collection at the National Museum of Denmark, Thomas Delbey from Cranfield University in England, and Ilaria Bonaduce from the University of Pisa, Italy, he has published a scientific article describing the results of their investigations into the brown-colored centaur head from the National Museum.

• The Parthenon: An Epic Monument Or a Mystery in Measurements?
• Centaurs in Greek Mythology: From the Iliad to Sagittarius and Harry Potter

The centaur head at the National Museum in Copenhagen.  a: front view;  b: rear view. The brown stains are clearly visible. (Courtesy of The National Museum of Denmark/Heritage Science Journal)

"We especially wanted to examine whether the brown film could have been formed by some biological organism, such as lichen, bacteria, algae, or fungi. This theory had been suggested before, but no specific organism had been identified. The same goes for the theory that it could be remnants of applied paint -- perhaps to protect or tone the marble surface," says Kaare Lund Rasmussen.

For their investigations, the research team was allowed to take five small samples from the back of the centaur head.

These samples underwent various analyses in SDU's laboratories, including protein analysis and so-called Laser Ablation Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry.

"We found no traces of biological matter in the brown layers -- only from our own fingerprints and perhaps a bird egg that broke on the marble in ancient times. This doesn't prove that there never was a biological substance, but it significantly reduces the probability, making the theory of a biological organism less probable now," says Kaare Lund Rasmussen.

Similarly, it is now less probable that the marble surface was painted or preserved, according to the researchers, who also specifically searched for traces of paint.

Ancient paints were typically based on natural products such as eggs, milk, and bones, and no traces of such ingredients were found in the brown stain alone.

The Mystery Remains

Through their investigations, the research team also discovered that the brown film consists of two separate layers.

These two layers are approximately equally thick, around 50 micrometers each, and they differ in terms of trace element composition.

However, both layers contain a mixture of the oxalate minerals weddellite and whewellite.

The fact that there are two distinct layers argues against the theory that they were created by the migration of material, such as iron particles, from the interior of the marble.

It also contradicts the theory that they resulted from a reaction with the air.

Air pollution is also unlikely for another reason; the centaur head has been indoors in Copenhagen since before the modern industrialization began in the 18th century.

In fact, this makes the heads at the National Museum of Denmark particularly valuable compared to the marble pieces on the Acropolis, of which some have only recently been brought indoors.

"As there are two different brown layers with different chemical compositions, it is likely that they have different origins. This could suggest that someone applied paint or a conservation treatment, but since we haven't found traces of such substances, the brown color remains a mystery," concludes Kaare Lund Rasmussen.

Top image: The Parthenon Centaur displayed in the National Museum in Copenhagen. Source: Courtesy of The National Museum of Denmark/Heritage Science Journal

The article ‘Despite Intensive Scientific Analyses, This Centaur Head Remains a Mystery’ was originally published on Science Daily. Source: Materials provided by University of Southern Denmark. Original written by Birgitte Svennevig. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.