Pottery Reveals America's First Social Media
By Jacob Lulewicz / Science Daily
Scientists have recently studied pottery produced by people living across southern Appalachia between 800 and 1650 AD. The unique symbols were stamped onto the pottery when the clay was still wet using carved wooden paddles. These designs, along with the varying characteristics of the specific kinds of clay used to produce the pottery, were used to reconstruct social networks among these communities.
Pottery As a Way of Communicating
Long before Snapchat, Instagram, Facebook, and even MySpace, early Mississippian Mound cultures in America's southern Appalachian Mountains shared artistic trends and technologies across regional networks that functioned in similar ways as modern social media, suggests new research from Washington University in St. Louis.
"Just as we have our own networks of 'friends' and 'followers' on platforms like Facebook and Twitter, societies that existed in North America between 1,200 and 350 years ago had their own information sharing networks," said Jacob Lulewicz, lecturer of archaeology in the Department of Anthropology in Arts & Sciences.
Examples of the kinds of pottery of ancient southern Appalachia. (Jacob Lulewicz / Washington University in St. Louis)
"Our study found a way to reconstruct these indigenous communication networks," he said. "Our analysis shows how these networks laid the groundwork for Native American political systems that began developing as far back as 600 AD."
The study utilizes sophisticated social network analysis to map social and political connections that helped unite friends and families in dozens of Native American villages well before the arrival of European explorers.
The findings are based on a messaging archive that is preserved not in bytes, but in bits of pottery sherds unearthed over many years in archaeology digs at dozens of Mississippian culture sites scattered across southern Appalachia.
What Does the Pottery Tell Us?
Focusing on subtle evolving changes in the technologies used to temper and strengthen pottery and the cultural symbols used to decorate them, the study provides a detailed chronological map of how new pottery techniques signified connections between these communities.
The ceramics database includes 276,626 sherds from 43 sites across eastern Tennessee, and 88,705 sherds from 41 sites across northern Georgia. The collection represents pottery created between 800 and 1650 AD, a period that saw the gradual emergence and later decline of powerful chiefdoms that controlled wide networks of villages in the region.
The study focuses on villages clustered around the site of Etowah in Bartow County, Georgia, an important Mississippian community that included several low earthen mounds with large ceremonial buildings. It served as the regional seat of social, political, economic, and religious power across the region -- influence that reached its peak between 1050 to 1325 AD.
These chiefdoms were still in place when the Spanish explorer Hernando de Soto became one of the first Europeans to visit the region in 1540 AD. De Soto's accounts of autonomous villages loosely bound together under the influence of a single powerful chief, then residing at the town of Coosa in what is today northern Georgia, have long influenced how historians characterize the social and political structures of these and other early Eastern North American societies.
An artist's conception of the Etowah site, 9BR1, a Mississippian culture archaeological site located on the banks of the Etowah River in Bartow County, Georgia. Built and occupied in three phases, from 1000–1550 AD. (Herb Roe / CC BY-SA 4.0)
The Use of Ancient Social Networks
Lulewicz' findings suggest that the ruling elites drew their power from social networks created by the masses.
The emergence of powerful Native American chiefdoms and the centralized leadership, elaborate religious movements, and institutionalized inequality that came with them, he argues, were built upon foundations created by the wider, pre-existing social networks of common people -- systems that proved to be more stable and durable than any interactions dictated by elite chiefs.
"What I show in the paper is that while we see things like the emergence of super powerful chiefs and the rise of major economic inequalities, the very foundations of society -- especially relationships and networks of kinship and family and reciprocity -- remained virtually unchanged over 1,000 years," Lulewicz said. "That is, even though elite interests and political strategies waxed and waned and collapsed and flourished, very basic relationships and networks were some of the strongest, most durable aspects of society."
- Titans Under the Earth: Evidence for The Tall Ones, and the Ancient Mounds of Pennsylvania
- The Mysterious Waffle Rock: A Bizarre Boulder with a Hazy Background
- 1,600-Year-Old Pottery Workshop Has First Known Rock-Hewn Kiln in Israel
A map of the southern Appalachian region, with the archaeological sites used in this study indicated. The sites are spread across both eastern Tennessee and northern Georgia and date to the period between 800 and 1650 AD. (Jacob Lulewicz / Washington University in St. Louis)
His findings suggest that strong social connections between common people have always played an important role in helping societies guard themselves against the vagaries of unpredictable leaders and ruling classes.
“Pointing to the role that digital social networks and social media play in contemporary revolutions, and how modern states are often quick to monitor, control or even shut down access to these virtual networks, shows that our connections continue to be valuable social instruments,” he said.
"This is super interesting - at least to me as a social scientist - for understanding how political movements actually play out," he said. "It doesn't come down to any particular, innate attribute of leaders and elites. What it comes down to is how those individuals are able to leverage the networks in which they are embedded. Even though chiefs emerged at about 1000 AD, over the next 650 years, chiefs actually shifted their strategies of political and economic control. They tap into different parts of their networks or leverage their connections in very different ways throughout time."
"Because these very basic networks were so durable, they allowed these societies, especially common people, to buffer against and mediate the uncertainties associated with major political and economic change. They may have said, 'You go live on top of that huge mound and do your sacred rituals, and we will go about life as usual for the most part.' These communication networks served as a social constant for these people and allowed their cultures to persist for thousands of years even across transformations that could have been catastrophic."
Jacob Lulewicz, Lecturer in Archaeology. (Jacob Lulewicz / Washington University in St. Louis)
Top image: Page 632 of "Annual report of the Bureau of American Ethnology to the Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution 1895" disks cut from sherds of stoneware from the South Appalachian region. Source: Internet Archive Book Images / Public Domain.
The article, originally titled. ‘Pottery reveals America's first social media networks: Ancient Indigenous societies, including Mississippian Mound cultures, were built through social networks.’ was originally published on Science Daily.
Source: Washington University in St. Louis. "Pottery reveals America's first social media networks: Ancient Indigenous societies, including Mississippian Mound cultures, were built through social networks." ScienceDaily. ScienceDaily, 19 February 2019. www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/02/190219143512.htm
Jacob Lulewicz. The social networks and structural variation of Mississippian sociopolitics in the southeastern United States. PNAS, 2019 DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1818346116