Fact Check Index

Every Fact Check we have published, in one place. Each card shows the claim we checked, the verdict we reached and the sources behind it. Pick a verdict below, or filter by topic and region.

24 Fact Checks so far. Labels apply to claims, not to whole articles, and can change when new research is published. How we check evidence

See which ancient sites our Fact Checks cover on the Atlas of the Ancient World, and how we check evidence.

Unverified Folklore and Belief Europe

Did Medieval People Drink Ale Because Water Was Unsafe?

Claim checked Medieval people drank ale because water was unsafe

By Aris Manus ·

Part verdicts (6)
  • Unverified Medieval people drank ale because water was unsafe
  • Established Medieval people drank water
  • Established Medieval towns piped in water for drinking
  • Established Medieval people knew some water could make them ill
  • Disputed Beer was the main drink where safe water was scarce
  • Unverified Medieval people chose ale because fermentation disinfects
Sources (5)
  1. Ælfric. Colloquy. Old English text. Wikisource
  2. Stow, John. A Survey of London (1603 text). Introduction by Henry B. Wheatley, edited by Ernest Rhys. Everyman edition. Project Gutenberg eBook 42959
  3. Chevallier, Jim. The great Medieval water myth. Les Leftovers
  4. Harvey, Katherine (2025). The vilest of all beverages. Wellcome Collection, December 18, 2025
  5. Ferriss, Tim (2021). The Tim Ferriss Show Transcripts: Michael Pollan, This Is Your Mind on Plants (#520). June 30, 2021
Read the Fact Check
Unverified Folklore and Belief Europe

Did Medieval People Believe the Earth Was Flat Until Columbus?

Claim checked Most people in the Middle Ages thought the Earth was flat until Columbus

By Aris Manus ·

Part verdicts (5)
  • Unverified Most people in the Middle Ages thought the Earth was flat until Columbus
  • Established Leading medieval writers taught that the Earth is a sphere
  • Established A few early Christian writers rejected a round Earth or people on its far side
  • Unverified Columbus's critics objected that the Earth was flat
  • Established Nineteenth century writers spread the story of a flat medieval Earth
Sources (11)
  1. Bede. De temporum ratione 32. Latin text. Bibliotheca Augustana
  2. Bede. Ecclesiastical History of England 1.1. Translated by A. M. Sellar. London: George Bell and Sons, 1907. Project Gutenberg
  3. John of Sacrobosco. The Sphere. Translated by Lynn Thorndike, 1949. Esoteric Archives
  4. The Travels of Sir John Mandeville. London: Macmillan, 1900. Project Gutenberg
  5. Lactantius. Divine Institutes 3.24. Translated by William Fletcher. Ante-Nicene Fathers Vol. 7. New Advent
  6. Augustine. City of God 16.9. Translated by Marcus Dods. Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series, Vol. 2. New Advent
  7. Irving, Washington. The Life and Voyages of Christopher Columbus, abridged by the author. 1838 printing. Internet Archive
  8. Draper, John William (1874). History of the Conflict Between Religion and Science. Project Gutenberg
  9. White, Andrew Dickson (1896). A History of the Warfare of Science with Theology in Christendom. Project Gutenberg
  10. Russell, Jeffrey Burton (1991). Inventing the Flat Earth: Columbus and Modern Historians. New York: Praeger. Internet Archive
  11. Russell, Jeffrey Burton (1997). The Myth of the Flat Earth. Lecture to the American Scientific Affiliation, August 4, 1997
Read the Fact Check
Disputed Folklore and Belief Europe

Halloween's Name Is Christian, and Its Samhain Roots Remain Disputed

Claim checked Halloween is descended from the Celtic festival of Samhain

By Aris Manus ·

Part verdicts (6)
  • Disputed Halloween is descended from the Celtic festival of Samhain
  • Established Samhain was a major festival at the start of November in medieval Ireland
  • Established Halloween takes its name and date from the eve of All Saints' Day, a Christian feast held on November 1 in the West by the ninth century
  • Unverified Samhain was the Celtic New Year
  • Unverified Samhain was a pagan festival of the dead
  • Unverified The Church placed All Saints and All Souls on November 1 and 2 to replace a pagan festival
Sources (4)
  1. Hutton, Ronald (2024). The Celtic New Year and Feast of the Dead. Folklore 135(1): 69 to 86. Published online March 14, 2024. Read in full
  2. Hutton, Ronald (2014). Halloween? It's more than trick or treat. The Guardian, October 28, 2014. Read in full
  3. Mershman, Francis (1907). All Saints' Day. The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 1. New York: Robert Appleton Company. Read in full
  4. Mershman, Francis (1907). All Souls' Day. The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 1. New York: Robert Appleton Company. Read in full
Read the Fact Check
Established Folklore and Belief EuropeAmericas

300 Years Ago Courts Still Executed Witches and Burned Their Bodies

Claim checked 300 years ago women were burned for witchcraft

By Aris Manus ·

Part verdicts (6)
  • Established 300 years ago women were burned for witchcraft. Reason: executions for witchcraft continued until 1782, burning of the body after execution is documented at Würzburg in 1749, and no source consulted for this check shows anyone burned alive after 1726
  • Established Most executions came long before 1726. Reason: Hutton places 80% of the deaths between 1560 and 1640
  • Established England and New England hanged convicted witches, and Scotland usually strangled them before burning. Reason: Levack's history and the Survey of Scottish Witchcraft, which found 120 of 141 recorded sentences were for strangling and burning
  • Established Men were a sizable minority of those accused. Reason: Levack estimates one-fifth to one-quarter across Europe, and men were the majority in Normandy, Russia, Estonia and Iceland
  • Established Most trials after 1550 were held in secular courts. Reason: Levack writes that trials were more commonly held in secular courts after 1550, and that Spain and Italy, where Inquisition courts kept control, saw relatively few prosecutions
  • Disputed The exact number executed. Reason: published estimates range from about 40,000 to about 60,000, and none supports the figure of 9 million sometimes repeated
Sources (5)
  1. Hutton, Ronald (2024). Witch-Hunting in European and World History. Gresham College lecture, June 5, 2024, transcript
  2. Levack, Brian P. (2006). The Witch-Hunt in Early Modern Europe. 3rd edition. Harlow: Pearson Longman. ISBN 978 0 582 41901 8. Read in a digital copy, including Table 5, Last executions and last trials for witchcraft
  3. Goodare, Julian, Lauren Martin, Joyce Miller and Louise Yeoman (2003). The Survey of Scottish Witchcraft: Frequently Asked Questions. University of Edinburgh
  4. Goodare, Julian, Lauren Martin, Joyce Miller and Louise Yeoman (2003). The Survey of Scottish Witchcraft. University of Edinburgh
  5. Gaar, Georg (1749). Christliche Anred Nächst dem Scheiter-Hauffen, Worauf der Leichnam Mariae Renatae, einer durchs Schwerdt Hingerichteten Zauberin. Frankfurt am Main: Rudolph. Catalog record and digital copy, Frankfurt University Library
Read the Fact Check
Fringe Ancient EgyptFolklore and Belief Africa

A 2002 Study of 25 People at Tutankhamun's Tomb Openings Found No Evidence of a Curse

Claim checked A curse from Tutankhamun's tomb killed members of the team that opened it

By Aris Manus ·

Part verdicts (6)
  • Fringe A curse from Tutankhamun's tomb killed members of the team that opened it
  • Established Lord Carnarvon died in Cairo on April 5, 1923, of pneumonia after an infected insect bite
  • Established People present at the key openings showed no significant difference in age at death or survival from other Westerners in Egypt at the time
  • Established Howard Carter, who led the excavation, lived until 1939
  • Unverified Mold spores inhaled in the tomb caused Carnarvon's death
  • Unverified A tablet at the entrance warned that death would strike anyone who entered
Sources (6)
  1. Nelson, Mark R. (2002). The mummy's curse: historical cohort study. BMJ 325: 1482 to 1484. Read in full (PubMed Central copy)
  2. Cox, Ann M. (2003). The death of Lord Carnarvon. The Lancet 361: 1994. Read in full
  3. El-Tawil, Sherif (2003). Lord Carnarvon's death: the curse of aspergillosis? The Lancet 362: 836. Read in full
  4. Marchant, Jo (2013). Why does the mummy's curse refuse to die? Aeon. Read in full
  5. Lord Carnarvon (obituary). Nature 111: 504 to 505, April 14, 1923. Read in full
  6. Howard Carter. Encyclopaedia Britannica. Read for dates of birth and death
Read the Fact Check