All  
Image of “Our Lady, Mother of Grace,” Trsat, Croatia (prob. 12th cent.)

An Empty Tomb and a Site Full of Faith: Where Was the Virgin Mary Buried?

Print

The Virgin Mary is one of the world most famous women from the ancient world. The teachings of her son surpassed her life story, but her tale provides one of the greatest legends about a mother's love. Nowadays, it's hard to find real artifacts that are said to be left by the Virgin Mother, but there is one place which is still traditionally associated with her.

There is a tomb at the foot of the Mount of Olives in the Kidron Valley in Jerusalem which is traditionally said to be Mary’s burial location. There are at least two versions of her story associated with this– one from the Bible and second from the Jewish ancient book Toledot Yeshu . Although the texts have some differences, they claim that Mary (or Miriam) was the mother of Joshua – also known as Jesus Christ.

Fact or Fiction?

Legends say that Mary died of natural causes. As the Dormition of Theotokos wrote, she passed away like she was falling asleep. It is unknown how old she was when she died. However, according to some writings, her body was resurrected and, like her son, on the third day her soul and body went to heaven. Her tomb was said to be discovered empty three days after her funeral.

Icon of the Dormition of the Theotokos (Virgin Mary), Dormition Church (Mary's Tomb), Jerusalem.

Icon of the Dormition of the Theotokos (Virgin Mary), Dormition Church (Mary's Tomb), Jerusalem. ( Public Domain)

The Catholic Encyclopedia asserts that the earliest resources talking about Mary suggest that her life ended in Jersusalem:

“The apocryphal works of the second to the fourth century are all favourable to the Jerusalem tradition. According to the Acts of St John by Prochurus, written (160-70) by Lencius, the Evangelist went to Ephesus accompanied by Prochurus alone and at a very advanced age, i.e. after Mary’s death. (...) The two letters B. Inatii missa S. Joanni, written about 370, show that the Blessed Virgin passed the remainder of her days at Jerusalem. That of Dionysius the Areopagite to the Bishop Titus (363), the Joannis liber de Dormitione Mariae (third to fourth century), and the treatise De transitu B.M. Virginis (fourth century) place her tomb at Gethsemane (..). There was never any tradition connecting Mary’s death and burial with the city of Ephesus.”

Many still doubt that the tomb really belonged to the Virgin Mary. In the 5th century AD, Cyril of Scythopolis wrote in Euthymiaca Historia that the Emperor Marcian and his wife Pulcheria asked for the relics of the the famous Mary. The Patriarch of Jerusalem, Juvenal, answered that there were no relics because Mary left her tomb three days after her funeral.

Altar in the Tomb of Mary, Jerusalem.

Altar in the Tomb of Mary, Jerusalem. ( CC BY SA 2.0 )

Mary’s Tomb

Since the early beginnings of Christianity, Mary’s supposed tomb has been considered a sacred site. The tomb was excavated in 1972 by Bellarmino Bagatti, an archaeologist and Franciscan friar. He believed that the site is an ancient cemetery dating back to the 1st century AD, and that it could contain burials of biblical heroes.

The team of researchers explored the three burial chambers and Bagatti decided that the tomb must be the one described by Christian sources as Mary’s famous tomb. In the 5th century, a small church was located near the tomb, but it was destroyed in 614 by the Persians.

Nonetheless, continued to be considered a sacred place during the Muslim domination. They believed that it was the burial place of the prophet Isa’s (Jesus’) mother. In 1130 AD, when the Crusaders arrived in Jerusalem, they rebuilt the church and installed Benedictines there.

Mary's Tomb.

Mary's Tomb. ( CC BY 2.0 )

The church was built in an early Gothic style, and could have been one of the most beautiful monasteries of Jerusalem, if it hadn't been destroyed by Saladin in 1187. However, the crypt remained untouched. It was rebuilt once more in the second half of the 14th century when it became a monastery for Franciscan friars, but it was officially expelled by the Franciscans in the 1757. The church was also intact during the Ottoman battles in Jerusalem.

Nowadays it contains the chapels of St Joseph, Joachim, and Anne (Mary's parents) and the tomb of Queen Melisende of Jerusalem. The crypt is still very mysterious because there is no physical evidence to verify the story which has been alive since ancient times. However, it is still possible that the chamber contained the Virgin Mary’s body for three days.

Virgin Mary's sarcophagus, inside the Church of Mary's Tomb, Mount of Olives, Jerusalem.

Virgin Mary's sarcophagus, inside the Church of Mary's Tomb, Mount of Olives, Jerusalem. ( CC BY SA 3.0 )

Moreover, the dating of the chambers is still uncertain. It is very difficult to identify the period of the tomb’s original structure. All of the tombs of the biblical period look similar. The funerary culture was very well planned, but rather ascetic. In this case, all that the researchers can do is to wonder about the story which has survived the last 2,000 years.

Searching for the Truth Behind the Tomb

Jesus’ mother Mary remains an icon of ancient history - one of the world’s most famous women of her times and the most important woman of Christianity. It is not surprising that her alleged tomb continues to be a huge tourist attraction.

But the tomb in Jerusalem that has been accepted by many as the real location of Mary’s burial is not her only possible tomb. One of the other suggested locations for her burial is in Turkmenistan, in a place called Mary, originally named Mari. People who live there believe that Jesus, Mary, and other people who were close with them traveled to India. However, Mary was said to have died in the territory of modern Turkmenistan. There is also a tomb for Jesus located in India, but that is a different story…

Top Image: Image of “Our Lady, Mother of Grace,” Trsat, Croatia (prob. 12th cent.) Source: Public Domain

By Natalia Klimczak

References:

J. Murphy-O’Connor, The Holy Land: An Oxford Archaeological Guide from Earliest Times to 1700, 2005.

Tomb of the Virgin Mary, availabe at:
http://www.sacred-destinations.com/israel/jerusalem-tomb-of-virgin-mary

Mary's Tomb, available at:
http://www.biblewalks.com/Sites/MarysTomb.html

Tomb of Mary, available at:
http://www.seetheholyland.net/tomb-of-mary/

Comments

Its good to see some new theories on old subjects but i would like to see more on australia

It is speculated (based on historical evidence rather than faith) that Jesus left Palestine after the crucifixion (he didn't die) and travelled to India with his mother Mary. Holger Kersten's book "Jesus Live in India" summarizes the tomb currently in Afghanistan.

“The historian Mullah Nadini (1413) also recounts a story of Yuz Asaf who was a contemporary to King Gopadatta, and confirms that he also used the name Issar, ie. Jesus. There is also much historical truth in the towns and villages of Northern India to prove that Jesus and his mother Mary spent time in the area. For instance, at the border of a small town called Mari, there is nearby a mountain called Pindi Point, upon which is an old tomb called Mai Mari da Asthan or "The final resting place of Mary". The tomb is said to be very old and local Muslims venerate it as the grave of Issa's (ie Christ's) Mother. The tomb itself is oriented East-West consistent with the Jewish tradition, despite the fact it is within a Muslim area. Assuming its antiquity, such a tomb could not be Hindu either since the Hindus contemporary to Christ cremated their dead and scattered their ashes as do Hindus today.”

Additionally, DNA has been taken from the tomb in hopes of matching it to the one interred in RosaBal in Kashmir (Jus Asaf) making a strong case for the mother son relationship. Politics, however, stands in the way of matching Mari’s DNA to that in the tomb at Rosa Bal in Srinigar Kashmir.

Pages

Next article