A concentration of bone and rock at the Cerutti Mastodon site in California, USA.

Criticisms Mount Against Claim of Hominins in the Americas Over 100,000 Years Ago


A startling claim was made almost a year ago: researchers said that they had evidence of hominins in the Americas at least 100,000 years before most people believed. They called for open-minded consideration of their evidence and have been met with debate. Skeptics say that there is no way the story is as it has been presented. But apart from a disbelief in the extremely old date, what else do they say does not fit?

One group of archaeologists has had their criticism published recently in Nature. They claim that the mastodon bone damage came about through disturbances at the site by modern construction equipment. Their evidence comes from “similar-looking damage, which was caused by natural wear and tear and heavy equipment” on mammoth bones that were found in Waco, Texas, USA. That collection of bones dates to approximately 60,000 years ago and came from 26 mammoths.

A Wooly mammoth (left) and an American mastodon (right) facing each other, showing the physical differences between the two animals.

A Wooly mammoth (left) and an American mastodon (right) facing each other, showing the physical differences between the two animals. (Dantheman9758/CC BY SA 3.0)

As Ancient Origins reported in April 2017, construction workers came across a collection of ancient bones in San Diego, California, USA in 1992. It took years of testing before an interdisciplinary team of researchers could ascertain that the mastodon bones date to 130,000 years ago. But with this information in hand an even more shocking claim was waiting to be made – there are marks the researchers assert were left on the bones by hominins.

A concentration of fossil bone and rock. The unusual positions of the femur heads, one up and one down, broken in the same manner next to each other is unusual. Mastodon molars are located in the lower right hand corner next to a large rock comprised of andesite which is in contact with a broken vertebra. Upper left is a rib angled upwards resting on a granitic pegmatite rock fragment.

A concentration of fossil bone and rock. The unusual positions of the femur heads, one up and one down, broken in the same manner next to each other is unusual. Mastodon molars are located in the lower right hand corner next to a large rock comprised of andesite which is in contact with a broken vertebra. Upper left is a rib angled upwards resting on a granitic pegmatite rock fragment. (San Diego Natural History Museum )

The researchers knew from the beginning that their date would be controversial. Thus, they waited 24 years to ascertain their facts before publishing their findings in the journal Nature. As they wrote in their paper:

“The earliest dispersal of humans into North America is a contentious subject, and proposed early sites are required to meet the following criteria for acceptance: (1) archaeological evidence is found in a clearly defined and undisturbed geologic context; (2) age is determined by reliable radiometric dating; (3) multiple lines of evidence from interdisciplinary studies provide consistent results; and (4) unquestionable artefacts are found in primary context.”

The Cerutti Mastodon site had spiral-fractured mastodon bone and molar fragments, many of which the team claim preserves evidence of percussion. The site also had flat rocks that could have been anvils and a collection of small stones that may have been used as hammers. These artifacts were found in the same layer as the mastodon bones and apparently show evidence of use wear and impact marks. The site is said to have looked “like a perfectly preserved tableau of an ancient tool-making workshop.”

Marks on mastodon bones – natural, construction damage, or evidence of hominins in the Americas over 100,000 years ago?

Marks on mastodon bones – natural, construction damage, or evidence of hominins in the Americas over 100,000 years ago? (Kate Johnson/ SDNHM)

Regarding the spiral fracture, Joseph Ferraro at Baylor University’s Institute of Archaeology in Waco, Texas, says “A dinosaur would break a leg. It happens. There are natural processes that could reasonably explain spiral fractures.” In general, Ferraro believes natural wear and construction work (some of the bones at Waco were found during a building project) explain the marks seen on the mastodon bones.

Thomas Deméré, principal paleontologist at the San Diego Museum of Natural History and one of the authors of the study under fire are standing by their claims. The team calls for critics to examine the bones in-person before putting forward their disagreements. Furthermore, they suggest the current criticism is based on superficial claims and an inappropriate comparison between the Cerutti Mastodon site and what has been found in Waco. Deméré also asserted “We’re really quite familiar with what kind of damage is caused by heavy equipment.”

A map of the Cerutti Mastodon site that shows fractured mastodon leg bones, bone fragments, broken molars, and tusks that lay clustered around two large stones—other stones lay nearby.

A map of the Cerutti Mastodon site that shows fractured mastodon leg bones, bone fragments, broken molars, and tusks that lay clustered around two large stones—other stones lay nearby. (San Diego Natural History Museum)

According to Ars Technica, there are two main arguments that have been provided against the paper: the site was too disturbed by construction to be reliable – such as Ferraro and his team state – or, simply, the evidence provided just isn’t enough to convince other researchers.

However, it is worth noting that the researchers didn’t take their results lightly and have already analyzed and compared their findings with mastodon bones from other North American sites dating from 14,000 to 33,000 years ago. They also conducted experiments to see if the kinds of stone tools found at the site could damage mastodon bones in the same way as they found them at Cerutti Mastodon. Their results “produced exactly the same kinds of fracture patterns that we see on the Cerutti mastodon limb bones,” said Holen, who added, “[W]e can eliminate all of the natural processes that break bones like this. These bones were not broken by carnivore-chewing, they were not broken by other animals trampling on the bone.”

Finally, the researchers have also provided a couple of possibilities for the stone tool creators – they wrote in their paper that Neanderthals or Denisovans may have been the ones who left the tools behind. Or, they put forward the idea that an early form of Homo sapiens who roamed Asia more than 200,000 years ago left the artifacts. With some evidence of possible boats in Indonesia 180,000 years ago and a climate that would have allowed for their passage to the Americas, there are a few contenders for who may have been the toolmakers at the site in California.

Top Image: A concentration of bone and rock at the Cerutti Mastodon site in California, USA. Source: San Diego Natural History Museum

By Alicia McDermott

Comments

It is so refreshing to see a serious & well written article that functions in reality & gets past the out-dated "afro-centric" origin of everything (mankind, civilization, frisbees, VW bugs).

So Ferraro is comparing a dinosour bone (whose speices is believed to be repitllian) to a Mastadon’s bone (which is clearly a mammalian species). He does realize that there is significant differences in their bones, right? Plus, he loses credibility if he hasn’t even examined the bones himself, yet tries to refute the findings of a professional who has.

Register to become part of our active community, get updates, receive a monthly newsletter, and enjoy the benefits and rewards of our member point system OR just post your comment below as a Guest.

Top New Stories

The first ever Roman boxing gloves found in Britain are now on display at Vindolanda.
Still molded to the form of their former owner’s knuckles, boxing gloves found at the Roman site of Vindolanda in Northumberland, England hint at tales of soldiers increasing their battle skills, keeping up their fitness, and passing the time gambling on fights while stationed in the far northern lands of the empire.

Myths & Legends

Human Origins

Silhouettes (Public Domain) in front of blood cells (Public Domain) and a gene.
Most people who have the Rh blood type are Rh-positive. There are also instances, however, where people are Rh-Negative. Health problems may occur for the unborn child of a mother with Rh-Negative blood when the baby is Rh-Positive.

Ancient Technology

The Lycurgus Cup.
A strange chalice made its way into the British Museum’s collection in the 1950s. It is a 1,600-year-old jade green Roman artifact called the Lycurgus Cup. The image on the chalice is an iconic scene with King Lycurgus of Thrace...

Our Mission

At Ancient Origins, we believe that one of the most important fields of knowledge we can pursue as human beings is our beginnings. And while some people may seem content with the story as it stands, our view is that there exists countless mysteries, scientific anomalies and surprising artifacts that have yet to be discovered and explained.

The goal of Ancient Origins is to highlight recent archaeological discoveries, peer-reviewed academic research and evidence, as well as offering alternative viewpoints and explanations of science, archaeology, mythology, religion and history around the globe.

We’re the only Pop Archaeology site combining scientific research with out-of-the-box perspectives.

By bringing together top experts and authors, this archaeology website explores lost civilizations, examines sacred writings, tours ancient places, investigates ancient discoveries and questions mysterious happenings. Our open community is dedicated to digging into the origins of our species on planet earth, and question wherever the discoveries might take us. We seek to retell the story of our beginnings. 

Ancient Image Galleries

View from the Castle Gate (Burgtor). (Public Domain)
Door surrounded by roots of Tetrameles nudiflora in the Khmer temple of Ta Phrom, Angkor temple complex, located today in Cambodia. (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Cable car in the Xihai (West Sea) Grand Canyon (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Next article