Array ( ) The Tale of Thorstein Shiver: Hell Confirmed for Pagans during Iceland Saga Age | Ancient Origins
Photo of Viking figures before a great fire. Would flames await Pagans in Hell?

The Tale of Thorstein Shiver: Hell Confirmed for Pagans during Iceland Saga Age


Short and succinct, the tale of Thorstein Shiver is one of the more comedic sagas and can be interpreted in at least two different ways: as religious or cultural propaganda.  The saga tells the brief story of Thorstein's encounter with a demon from Hell, amusing in its treatment of both the demon and two characters who have been damned.  Though it is a very short saga, the tale of Thorstein Shiver promotes Christian ideology attempted to be implemented by Olaf Tryggvason by depicting him as a compassionate leader and using the character of the demon to confirm the Christian perception of Hell. 

Museum in Reykjavik contains figures like these which tell the history of early Iceland - the saga age.

Museum in Reykjavik contains figures like these which tell the history of early Iceland - the saga age. Shadowgate/Flickr

The story opens with a description of the Norwegian king Olaf Tryggvason and the highlighting of Thorstein Thorkelsson as an Icelandic man traveling with the king and his company.  As Olaf was traveling in the region of Vik, Thorstein found himself staying on a farm in Reim for the night. Olaf commanded that all his men stay together if a need arose to go to the privy in the middle of the night.  Travel in pairs, the king ordered, or else each transgressor would be found guilty of disobeying their king.

Illustration, King Olaf I of Norway

Illustration, King Olaf I of Norway. Public Domain

Thorstein, as one would expect, was the sole man to awaken in the middle of the night needing to relieve himself. Ignoring the king's orders, he went to the relief chamber alone and was almost immediately confronted by a demon. A very calm, relaxed discussion between the two began.

Thorstein asked who the demon was: a man called Thorkel the Thin, who supposedly died on the battlefield against a king named Harald War-Tooth.  However, never in the text is he directly referred to as Thorkel the Thin except when he introduces himself.

Thorstein asked the demon a series of questions about the conditions of Hell and the people who are condemned there. The demon told Thorstein about two particular people in Hell: the one who suffers the most and the one who deals with suffering the worst.

The former award went to Sigurd Fafnirsson, the dragon slayer from the Volsunga Saga.  He was named such for slaying the serpent Fafnir at the behest of his foster-father Regin, and later went on to love the Valkyrie Brunhild before losing his life at her hands when a potion forced him to forget her. Upon his death, he passed into Hell and became—according to the demon—both the kindle and kindling for the fire in a very large oven.

MORE

The second person the demon discusses is a man called Starkad the Old, who committed as many good deeds as crimes.  Starkad is also documented in Gautrek's Saga as having sacrificed King Vikar after a succession of lots decided that Vikar was requested by Odin as a sacrifice.  Though Starkad initially was not going to sacrifice his king, Odin met with him in person and made the appeal, thus Starkad saw it through. 

The demon tells that Starkad's punishment in Hell is to be immersed up to his ankles in fire, a fate not so awful until the demon admits to Thorstein that Starkad hangs upside down, his screams a torment to all other members of Hell. Thorstein requests to hear such a scream, the worst of Starkad's, and passes out from the sheer horror of it. The demon finally left Thorstein in peace when a church bell tolled, startling both himself and Thorstein.

The next morning, Thorstein confessed his ill-doing to the king, afraid of what would happen if he was found out without confessing. He also wanted to share his bizarre experience.  Olaf forgave Thorstein's disobedience and informed him that Olaf already knew of the demon, and that it was Olaf himself who commanded the church bells rung, as he did not believe the demon would otherwise leave Thorstein alone. 

Thorstein, however, claimed that the demon had not frightened him as Olaf believed. There had been no fear in Thorstein's heart, he told his leader, merely a small shiver up his spine at the screams the demon produced. It was then that Olaf dubbed Thorstein as Thorstein the Shiver, a comment on his bravery far surpassing those of the Norwegians, and the tale comes to a dénouement.

From the Grettis Saga: Grettir is ready to fight in this illustration from a 17th-century Icelandic manuscript. Public Domain

Closer examination of this tale, however, reveals the political and religious promotion earlier referenced. It is evident that the author was attempting to reveal the success of Olaf Tryggvason’s conversions, as the Icelander Thorstein did not argue Olaf’s comments about Hell, but rather agreed with it. The indication that there is suffering in Hell was a highly Christian idea; before the coming of this new faith, Hel was only one of the places where mankind went after death, and it was not always terrifying. Indeed, it was similar to the Greek idea that Hades was the place where all the dead went; the Elysian Fields was a small portion of the underworld where the good souls enjoyed their afterlife.  Or, in the Norse cosmos, the fallen warriors went to Valhalla, to train and wait for the final battle known as Ragnarök.

In addition to this, the characters the author chose to discuss as dwelling in Hell were two pre-Christian heroes—Sigurd the Dragon-Slayer was beloved by a Valkyrie of Odin’s, and Starkad the Old was considered in various texts as being part giant. By describing these two people's experiences in Hell to Thorstein, the demon symbolically cements that all pre-Christian ideas were false.

Despite the conciseness of the tale of Thorstein Shiver, it was cleverly executed to confirm uncertain Christian ideas for the period the text discusses. The date of the manuscript encompasses an already Christian era, but the date that is depicted is considered the bridge between the Christian and pre-Christian faiths—as Olaf Tryggvason himself was one of the most successful converters despite his tactics. The conversation between Thorstein and demon seamlessly aligns to insinuate to medieval readers that their perception of Hell was accurate, thereby solidifying their newly adopted worldview as the true faith to follow.

Detail of a miniature from a 13th-century Icelandic manuscript.

Detail of a miniature from a 13th-century Icelandic manuscript. Public Domain

Featured image:  Photo of Viking figures before a great fire. Would flames await Pagans in Hell? Pure Calamity/Flickr

Bibliography

Edith Hamilton. Mythology (Warner Books: New York, 1969.)

Thomas D. Hill. "Gestr's 'Prime Sign': Source and Signification in Norna-Gests þáttr." Arkiv for Nordisk Filologi 104 (1989): 103-22.

Neil Price, The Viking World (Routledge: London, 2008.)

Alexandra Sanmark. Power and conversion: a comparative study of Christianization in Scandinavia; Uppsala (Department of Archaeology and Ancient History: Uppsala University, 2002.)

Unknown. Seven Viking Romances. Trans. Hermann Pálsson and Paul Edwards (London: Penguin, 1985.)

By Ryan Stone

Comments

Re: "Olaf dubbed Thorstein as Thorstein the Shiver, a comment on his bravery far surpassing those of the Norwegians, "

That would most likely be "Christians", not "Norwegians". It seems to be an essential part of this story that Olaf is not there in his capacity as Norwegian, nor in his capacity as king, but in his capacity as Christian. Perhaps even "missionary" aka "crusader" in a later wording, I am not sure about that.

That saga (like all other sagas) is more rich than it looks like at the surface. That the story has a set of "extra meanings" or "multiple layers" could (could!) indicate that the saga may be genuinely Norse.

However, there are caveats, example: How Starkad and Sigurd would end up in a place, "Hell", that to them does not even exist (as, afaik, they were not Christians). This defies explanation as well as reason. This saga blends concepts from two incomparable (even incommensurate) worldviews, and hence either it was authoured by a supreme master poet (in contemporary speak: a genius), or it is fake/Christian.

To properly determine if the saga is of Norse or Christian origin would require the mental capacity and knowledge of one of my forbearers, and intellect like that is hardly available anywhere these days, if at all.

All above is imho, afaik... and I'm not a doctor/lawyer, etc. Even if I was, do not believe too much in authourities or dogma. That is an important part of Norse culture, and it is even part of this particular saga.

Further, adding mention of "Hades" to the mix you are seriously confusing matters. Hades did not exist to the Old Norse, and it did not exist to the Christians either. So, that mention is 100% irrelevant and misleading.

Please note that Hel and Hell is _not_ the same. This quote is potentially very misleading:

"Hell was a highly Christian idea; before the coming of this new faith, Hel was "
... as you are putting one concept in succession of another, which you cannot do as the two very different concepts are simply not even comparable.

What Hel was "before", Hel was also "after". Indeed, Hel is Hel to this very day, and I assume that Hell has not changed either, but Christian concepts have been known to change in the past, so one never knows. Still the two are _not_ the same.

Hell is a christian concept, and it does not exist outside a Christian worldview.

Hel is an Old Norse concept, and it does not exist outside of a Norse worldview.

Hence, a Christian could be (and most likely would be) fully ignorant about Hel, and a Norse could be (and most likely would be) fully ignorant about Hell.

Hell was simply non-existant to a Norse "Old Believer" and Hel was non-existing to a Christian. It still is so, some 1,400 years later.

You cannot assume that "Hel" is something similar to "Hell", only earlier. That would be very wrong. The two are not only unlike, they are fully incommensurate. They're as different as apples and pagodas.

Register to become part of our active community, get updates, receive a monthly newsletter, and enjoy the benefits and rewards of our member point system OR just post your comment below as a Guest.

Human Origins

Map of sites and postulated migratory pathways associated with modern humans dispersing across Asia during the Late Pleistocene.
Most people are now familiar with the traditional "Out of Africa" model: modern humans evolved in Africa and then dispersed across Asia and reached Australia in a single wave about 60,000 years ago. However, technological advances in DNA analysis and other fossil identification techniques, as well as an emphasis on multidisciplinary research

Ancient Technology

Detail of a star chart dating to the Middle Kingdom.
The calendar is one of mankind’s most important inventions. Calendars allowed societies to organize time for religious, social, economic, and administrative purposes. The calendar, or rather, two sets of calendars, were invented by the ancient Egyptians. One of these was a lunar calendar, which was used mainly for the organization of religious festivals.

Ancient Places

Smuts house
The farmstead of General Jan Smuts on the outskirts of Pretoria, is reputed to be one of the most haunted private homes in the country, according to Mr Mark Rose-Christie, raconteur and social scientist, who regularly takes brave visitors on a tour of haunted sites on his mystery ghost bus.

Our Mission

At Ancient Origins, we believe that one of the most important fields of knowledge we can pursue as human beings is our beginnings. And while some people may seem content with the story as it stands, our view is that there exists countless mysteries, scientific anomalies and surprising artifacts that have yet to be discovered and explained.

The goal of Ancient Origins is to highlight recent archaeological discoveries, peer-reviewed academic research and evidence, as well as offering alternative viewpoints and explanations of science, archaeology, mythology, religion and history around the globe.

We’re the only Pop Archaeology site combining scientific research with out-of-the-box perspectives.

By bringing together top experts and authors, this archaeology website explores lost civilizations, examines sacred writings, tours ancient places, investigates ancient discoveries and questions mysterious happenings. Our open community is dedicated to digging into the origins of our species on planet earth, and question wherever the discoveries might take us. We seek to retell the story of our beginnings. 

Ancient Image Galleries

View from the Castle Gate (Burgtor). (Public Domain)
Door surrounded by roots of Tetrameles nudiflora in the Khmer temple of Ta Phrom, Angkor temple complex, located today in Cambodia. (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Cable car in the Xihai (West Sea) Grand Canyon (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Next article