Egypt Exodus

Egypt Remembers: Ancient accounts of the Great Exodus

(Read the article on one page)

The biblical story of the Israelites’ Descent and Exodus speaks about important events that took place in Egypt, so we should expect to find records of these events in Egyptian sources – the seven years of famine predicted by Joseph, the arrival of his father Jacob with his Hebrew family from Canaan, the great plagues of Moses, the death of Egypt’s first born, including the Pharaoh’s first son, and the drowning of the Pharaoh himself in the Red Sea; all these events should have been recorded by the scribes who kept detailed records of daily life. But we do not find even one contemporary inscription from the relevant period that records any of these events.

Egyptian Scribe

Egyptian scribes were tasked with recording important events, yet there are no records of the biblical story of the Israelites’ Descent and Exodus. ‘The Scribe’, Louvre Museum. Credit: Jean-Pierre Dalbéra / flickr .

In spite of this silence, the name of Israel has been found inscribed on one of the pharaonic stele, although with no connection either to Moses or the Exodus. However, although the Merenptah stele locates the Israelites in Canaan around 1219 BC, it makes no mention of them previously living in Egypt or departing from it in an Exodus under Moses.    

Merneptah Stele

Merneptah Stele known as the Israel stele (JE 31408) from the Egyptian Museum in Cairo. Credit: Wikipedia

This complete silence of official Egyptian records was later broken by Egyptian historians, who appear to have known many details about Moses and his Exodus. While contemporary pharaonic authorities seem to have deliberately suppressed the mention of Moses and his followers in their records, popular traditions retained the story of the man whom Egyptians regarded as a divine being, for more than 10 centuries, before it was recorded by Egyptian priests. Under the Macedonian Ptolemaic Dynasty, which ruled Egypt after the death of Alexander the Great in 323 BC, Egyptian historians made sure to include the story of Moses and his exodus in their historical accounts.

Manetho, the 3 rd century BC Egyptian priest and historian who recorded the history of Egypt into Greek to be placed in the Library of Alexandria, included the story of Moses in his Aegyptiaca. According to Manetho, Moses was an Egyptian and not a Hebrew, who lived at the time of Amenhotep III and his son Akhenaten (1405-1367 BC). Manetho also indicated that the Israelites’ Exodus took place in the reign of a succeeding king whose name was Ramses.

Papyrus - Manetho

Papyrus from the fifth century AD, suspected partial copy of the Epitome, based on Manetho’s Aegyptiaca. Credit: Wikipedia

Although Manetho’s original text was lost, some quotations from it have been preserved mainly by the Jewish historian Flavius Josephus in 1 st century AD. Commenting on Manetho’s account of Moses, Josephus tells us that:

Under the pretext of recording fables and current reports about the Jews, he (Manetho) took the liberty of introducing some incredible tales, wishing to represent us (the Jews) as mixed up with a crowd of Egyptian lepers and others, who for various maladies were condemned, as he asserts, to banishment from the country. Inventing a king named Amenophis, an imaginary person, the date of whose reign he consequently did not venture to fix … This king, he states, wishing to be granted … a vision of the gods, communicated his desire to his namesake, Amenophis, son of Paapis (Habu), whose wisdom and knowledge of the future were regarded as marks of divinity. This namesake replied that he would be able to see the gods if he purged the entire country of lepers and other polluted persons.
Delighted at hearing this, the king collected all the maimed people in Egypt, numbering 80,000, and sent them to work in the stone-quarries on the east of the Nile, segregated from the rest of the Egyptians. They included, he adds, some of the learned priests, who were afflicted with leprosy. Then this wise seer Amenophis was seized with a fear that he would draw down the wrath of the gods on himself and the king if the violence done to these men were detected; and he added a prediction that the polluted people would find certain allies who would become masters of Egypt for thirteen years. He did not venture to tell this himself to the king, but left a complete statement in writing, and then put an end to himself. The king greatly disheartened.”
[Against Apion, Flavius Josephus, Harvard University Press, 1926, p. 258-259].  

Josephus was wrong in saying that Manetho invented a king named Amenophis who communicated his desire to his namesake, Amenophis, son of Paapis. This king has been identified as Amenhotep III, 9 th king of the 18 th Dynasty, while his namesake, Amenhotep son of Habu, is known to have started his career under Amenhotep III as an Inferior Royal Scribe. He was promoted to be a Superior Royal Scribe, and finally reached the position of Minister of all Public Works. On the other hand, Manetho’s description of the rebels as being “lepers and polluted people” should not be taken literary to mean that they were suffering from some form of physical maladies - the sense was that they were seen as impure because of their denial of Egyptian religious beliefs.

Comments

You seem to be pre-disposed to accept the orthodox, Biblical version of history. Yet, while you note Egyptians had a tendency to record historical events in a way flattering to themselves, you fail to consider that the Hebrews did the same throughout the Bible. The books of Moses were written several hundred years after his time, when the Hebrew people were held in captivity in Babylon.

During that time, the Chief Rabbis faced a great challenge of keeping up the moral of their people. They wrote the mythic books of Moses then to give their people a strong sense of cohesive nationalism. The mythos of their formerly persecuted history was developed. Actually, Abraham and the Hebrew tribe was part of the Hyksos invasion of Egypt, where they oppressed the Egyptians for over 150 years. Ultimately the Egyptians paid an enormous ransom to the Hebrews and the rest of the Hyksos to leave their land. All this is recorded by Josephus and Mantheo. History now refers to this as the Hyksos expulsion.

The Hebrew Rabbis in Babylon were epic story-tellers who knew that tales of their history as former oppressors would not be compelling to their flock. However, if they related heroic stories of an oppressed people who were so favored by God that he created plaques to free them would develop pathos and a strong identity, reinforced by a Torah from God and endlessly repeated readings, songs and rituals.

I've found the books by Ralph Ellis he wrote about Egypt to be very illuminating. And I recommend them to you. The rest of his books are excellent as well. I like his unorthodox revelations that seemed very well researched and referenced. And they make a lot of sense to me.

All great information - great article as well as well thought-out comments. There are certainly some very educated readers on this website!

I just want to point out the famous maxim: History is written by the victors. It does not surprise me that there is very little Egyptian evidence for the Exodus.

#1 - the Egyptians were notorious editors of history. All one has to do is look at the vast amount of effort expended over the centuries to wipe out the memories of past pharaohs whose reigns were somehow offensive to the current House in power. Statues destroyed, inscriptions wiped out, complete temples destroyed.

#2 - the Exodus was an embarrassment to the Egyptians. According to Biblical records, the Exodus was a blatant indictment of the false Egyptian religious system, that the Hebrew YHWH was, in fact, the One True God. So, of course, the Egyptians didn't record that. It would be like England putting up huge memorials to the Colonies' victory and subsequent creation of the US of A, or the South erecting statues of Union Generals from the war that is still referred, to this day, as the War of Northern Aggression.

This non-record of the Exodus is not evidence that it didn't exist, no more than the non-record of the use of electricity 500 years ago indicates that electricity didn't exist 500 years ago. In my opinion, it was not politically correct, in dynastic times, to memorialize what was certainly an embarrassing era in Egyptian history.

The Egyptians did write an account of the Exodus.

Firstly, there is a complete Egyptian record of the Exodus, inscribed on the Tempest Stele of Ahmose I. This records the giving of tribute, in the form of gold, silver, cloth and oil, to the Hyksos leaders to induce them to leave Egypt - exactly as the Book of Exodus says. And since this stele was buried for 3000 years, we know it is original and independent from the biblical account.

Secondly, Manetho via Josephus, gives TWO exodus accounts, not one. And Josephus is adamant that the first exodus out if Egypt was the Hyksos exodus, and that the Hyksos were the Israelites (our people, as he calls them). So the Israelites are the Hyksos Egyptians.

The quote in this article is from the second exodus, which was indeed the Akhenaton exodus. Which is why the Israelite god was called Adon - the god of Akhenaton.

The biblical account has conflated these two events into a single exodus. See 'Jesus, Last of the Pharaohs', and 'Tempest & Exodus'.

Ralph

Thanks Ahmed, good to see you still researching.
To reinforce your argument, This is an account of the Great Hyksos Exodus.

The people were called shepherds.
They were circumcised and wore earrings.
Their leader was called Pharaoh Jacoba.
There was an ashfall.
There was three days of darkness, and hail.
Many Egyptians perished.
There was a war with the Egyptians.
A million people were pushed out of Egypt on an exodus.
The Egyptians gave them gold, oil and cloth to leave.
They left from Pi Ramesse (Avaris)
They travelled to The Levant.
They destroyed Jericho en-route.

Sound familiar? Yes, indeed, but these are the historical events of the Hyksos Exodus from Egypt, not the biblical story. So the Israelites and the Hyksos were the same people - just as Josephus Flavius himself claims.

See Jesus, Last of the Pharaohs.

Ralph

Tsurugi's picture

Oh. Really? Wikipedia says, "The earliest and only surviving reference to Manetho's Aegyptiaca is that of the Jewish historian Josephus in his work Against Apion."

This is what I have heard and read in various places over the years, which is why I said it. Could be wrong, not disputing that. What works of other authors are you referring to?

Pages

Register to become part of our active community, get updates, receive a monthly newsletter, and enjoy the benefits and rewards of our member point system OR just post your comment below as a Guest.

Top New Stories

The Pylos Combat Agate, an ancient object found in Pylos, Greece and created around 1450 BC.
The discovery of the Pylos Combat Agate in a Mycenaean shaft-grave tomb dating to 1500 BC may be one of the most significant archaeological and artistic finds in decades, perhaps in centuries. The level of artistic sophistication and detail are stunning -- the more so because the piece itself is so small and the level of detail is so incredibly high.

Myths & Legends

Human Origins

Sumerian creation myth
Sumer , or the ‘land of civilized kings’, flourished in Mesopotamia, now modern-day Iraq, around 4500 BC. Sumerians created an advanced civilization with its own system of elaborate language and...

Ancient Technology

Detail of a star chart dating to the Middle Kingdom.
The calendar is one of mankind’s most important inventions. Calendars allowed societies to organize time for religious, social, economic, and administrative purposes. The calendar, or rather, two sets of calendars, were invented by the ancient Egyptians. One of these was a lunar calendar, which was used mainly for the organization of religious festivals.

Ancient Places

The public entrance to the Unicorn Cave.
Einhornhöhle, which may be translated as ‘Unicorn Cave’ in English, is a cave located in the Harz, a low mountain range in a highland area Northern Germany. It has been pointed out that the Unicorn Cave is the largest cave in the western Harz that is open to the public.

Our Mission

At Ancient Origins, we believe that one of the most important fields of knowledge we can pursue as human beings is our beginnings. And while some people may seem content with the story as it stands, our view is that there exists countless mysteries, scientific anomalies and surprising artifacts that have yet to be discovered and explained.

The goal of Ancient Origins is to highlight recent archaeological discoveries, peer-reviewed academic research and evidence, as well as offering alternative viewpoints and explanations of science, archaeology, mythology, religion and history around the globe.

We’re the only Pop Archaeology site combining scientific research with out-of-the-box perspectives.

By bringing together top experts and authors, this archaeology website explores lost civilizations, examines sacred writings, tours ancient places, investigates ancient discoveries and questions mysterious happenings. Our open community is dedicated to digging into the origins of our species on planet earth, and question wherever the discoveries might take us. We seek to retell the story of our beginnings. 

Ancient Image Galleries

View from the Castle Gate (Burgtor). (Public Domain)
Door surrounded by roots of Tetrameles nudiflora in the Khmer temple of Ta Phrom, Angkor temple complex, located today in Cambodia. (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Cable car in the Xihai (West Sea) Grand Canyon (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Next article