All  

Ancient Origins Tour IRAQ

Ancient Origins Tour IRAQ Mobile

Here you can navigate quickly through all comments made in any article sorted by date/time.

  • Reply to: Resurrecting Ancestry: Genetic Revelations Beyond Israelites   1 min 8 sec ago
    Comment Author: Cataibh

    I stopped reading at "Y. Harari’s excellent book Jewish Magic before the Rise of Kabbalah."

    I have no doubt God would describe it as something other than excellent. The Devil, on the other hand...

  • Reply to: Previously Undetected Roman Remains Found in Lead Coffin   50 min 55 sec ago
    Comment Author: Nicko4404

    There are many examples of Roman lead coffins, this is just the first one found in Yorkshire that's all. As for Ice Ages during the Iron Ages, I note it's P Wagner, read a book yet?

  • Reply to: Previously Undetected Roman Remains Found in Lead Coffin   2 hours 45 min ago
    Comment Author: CityofTin

    What always intrigues me more is how anything found in Britain is always lumped into the 'Roman' category, which is so catch all. These were staggering periods of change, trade, crossover and numerous tribes. We are always left to assume that by 'Roman' these finds must be 'of Rome' yet there's no idea whether they were, or were just OF that Roman era of British history. And which would therefore throw the door wide open to other explanations.

    Of course we can never fully know, but the moniker is handed out very liberally to items, practices or peoples that may ultimately turn out not to be a direct product of Rome or a Roman/fully Roman tradition.

    I'm not a purist of any group, and ultimately actual products of Rome are what they are. I'd just like to see more accuracy reflected within academia, rather than us left to assume because of gaps.

  • Reply to: Decrypting the Temple of Edfu and the Edfu Texts   15 hours 1 min ago
    Comment Author: Sotirov

    Dear Wu, thank you for the nice strory! I have a question. Can you help me with some information about an inscription in the Edfu Temple containing the very large number 1.333.330? I saw its photo (https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpreview.redd.it%2Fthe-num...) but with no indication. I would be grateful to obtain your answer on my mail [email protected].

    With best wishes,

  • Reply to: Ancient Ship Graveyard Embroiled In Biblical Flood Mystery   2 days 3 hours ago
    Comment Author: Tabletop
    Ark

    Hear,Hear!

  • Reply to: How about a "Books and Literature" forum?   2 days 16 hours ago
    Comment Author: Ancient Soul Bo...

    Alternatively, how about a place for fledgling historical fiction writers to get feedback for accuracy sake?

    I have a work in progress setting Moses’s fleeing Egypt near the end of Amenhotep III’s reign and would love to share the link (writing it on Google Docs so it can be shared) to get historical critiques

  • Reply to: Lorenzo de' Medici: the ‘Magnificent’ Patron of the Renaissance   3 days 8 hours ago
    Comment Author: Cataibh

    "Despite his young age, Lorenzo proved to be a skilled politician and diplomat, adept at navigating the complex web of alliances and rivalries that characterized Italian city-states at the time. He skillfully maintained the Medici's grip on power..."

    It is said that power corrupts but, in reality, it attracts the already corrupted. The Medicis were very attracted to power. Should we be praising Lorenzo's skill, or condemning his family's corruption?

    Historians too often glorify that which has little inherent glory. Being a patron of the arts, for example, does not paint over one's corruption in the eyes of God. But then the Medicis only pretended to look to God. It is telling that the education Lorenzo received is described as "humanist" rather than 'Godly'.

  • Reply to: New Barrier Reef Find Proves Australians Didn’t Learn Pottery from Europe   4 days 20 hours ago
    Comment Author: Cataibh

    Do we know for sure this was shared technology? It may have been that, but it may have also simply been Lapita/Papuan presence in the area which should hardly be surprising. If it was shared technology with a local Aboriginal tribe, the technology appears to have died out in Australia. There is not a single shred of good evidence for Aboriginal pottery at the tine of European exploration although, as good evidence and Australian anthropology long ago parted company, I guess that doesn't so much matter...

  • Reply to: Why So Few Witches Were Executed in Wales in the Middle Ages   6 days 5 hours ago
    Comment Author: Cataibh

    There are witches today. Some are herbalists dabbling stupidly in the Occult. Others are more akin to the witch in the Hansel and Gretel fairytale with all that implies regarding child abuse.

    The latter are master manipulators, keen to control the narrative on the subject and to normalise the abnormal. I urge readers to be generally cautious for the probability that they can spot the latter is extremely low. In fact, from what I've seen, it's basically zero.

  • Reply to: Spice, Spice, Baby: The Dutch East-India Company   1 week 3 days ago
    Comment Author: Cataibh

    "Would McDonalds invade New Zealand because their government banned the sale of Big Macs?"

    No, because they don't need to. Both McDonalds and the NZ government are controlled by the same forces. Historians should read Machiavelli's infamous tome and attempt to understand it. A court jester was paid by the king to, at times, lampoon him, not because the king wanted to be lampooned but because he didn't want to be. Taking things like the reason why a court jester exists at face value is the short way to serfdom. The NZ government plays the role of court jester and the Sherriff of Nottingham simultaneously.

  • Reply to: Spice, Spice, Baby: The Dutch East-India Company   1 week 3 days ago
    Comment Author: Cataibh

    The penultimate sentence below should have been "They rarely stand up and, instead, go with the status quo."

    I post this as a reply as I cannot edit it.

  • Reply to: Spice, Spice, Baby: The Dutch East-India Company   1 week 3 days ago
    Comment Author: Cataibh

    "Google’s unofficial motto ‘Don’t be evil,’ would’ve been handy for the VoC four centuries ago, because they were, undoubtedly, evil."

    And Google isn't evil? People don't change much and neither do massive global corporations. The commonplace idea that power corrupts misses the point almost completely.

    Power attracts the already corrupted, just like the VoC did, which cuts out the middle man, again just like the VoC did, and simplifies the process. Corporations like Google have massive power. They're just better at mind control these days, so people don't notice how they're reacting to Google in the same soft manner that people reacted to the VoC with.

    That it couldn't happen today is just another commonplace myth that salves the conscience unjustifiably. It can happen today and does and shall continue to because millions, and perhaps billions, don't notice and often don't want to notice.

    People are usually timid. They rarely stand up and go with the status quo. So is and does this article.

  • Reply to: Seven Great Religious Leaders in History (Video)   1 week 4 days ago
    Comment Author: Cataibh

    "...many historians also believe that Jesus was based on a real historical figure..."

    Quìtè a few successful historians secretly worship the Devil. The Devil ensures their success in academia and in prìnt and on television. In return, they question either the divinity or the existence of Jesus.

  • Reply to: Seven Great Religious Leaders in History (Video)   1 week 4 days ago
    Comment Author: Cataibh

    One may reduce the ĺìst to two, including one not mentioned.

    Namely, Jesus and the Devil.

    The choice between the two is yours.

  • Reply to: Why Are Humans So Vain Compared to Other Animals? (Video)   2 weeks 2 days ago
    Comment Author: Cataibh

    People are capable of expressing vanity in a way animals are not. However, that doesn't mean all animals are incapable of vanity. To give a cat, for example, a human ability of such expression would not be something I would want to see.

  • Reply to: The Knights of the Star and their Giant Sacred Pentagram in France   2 weeks 2 days ago
    Comment Author: Cataibh

    There's quite a bit of questionable Judaeo-Christianity in this. The menorah is certainly linked to the Old Testament but, equally, it is in more modern times linked to the Occult. The latter links are too obvious to be ignored, once known. Positioning in a cathedral does not necessarily negate this.

    To truly follow the symbolism is, ultimately, to end up contemplating the ease at which the Devil hijacks Godly symbolism for ungodly purposes.

    Anything less than that is either misleading or being misled.

  • Reply to: Why Are Humans So Vain Compared to Other Animals? (Video)   2 weeks 2 days ago
    Comment Author: Archaeologist

    While I do agree that we’re a very vain species, we’re not alone in this category.  Many bird species strut their stuff, puff their feathers and sing distinctive courting songs.  In this respect, we’re one of many species who are vain.

    It’s normal to want to look our best and other species do this as well.  Cats, for example are always licking their coats to spruce them up.  We like to think we’re the smartest of all animal species, but how do we know this for sure, when we can’t speak their languages?

  • Reply to: Avalon: Island of Apples   2 weeks 3 days ago
    Comment Author: Nicko4404

    I don't believe, as with a lot that Plutarch wrote, that Avalon was copied from Elysium Fields. Apart from the fact that the myths are completely different, the fact that it was a foundation myth for the Irish indicates that it's considerably older than Latin civilisation. And, as with a lot of things "Roman" ie roads, heavy wheeled traffic legionary helmets etc possibly the other way around. In Tasmania, I know that the Irish convicts were amazed that here the apple trees both flower and fruit at the same time, previously only something that happened in Avalon

  • Reply to: What Life Was Really Like as a Medieval Jester (Video)   2 weeks 5 days ago
    Comment Author: Tara Mishra

    We could do with much more humour as a vehicle for social commentary and political influence in this day and age

  • Reply to: The Strange Truth About Neanderthal Sex Lives (Video)   2 weeks 6 days ago
    Comment Author: Cataibh

    The strange truth about mind control is that if one develops a myriad of interconnected lies, often based òn half-truths at best, and repeat them often enough, people can be prevented from searching for the truth.

    After all, they are certain that they already know it.

    Is Crohn's caused by Neanderthal genetics, or are there other factors? That is not to rule out genetics, for illness can even be encouraged through genetic targeting and there are those more than willing to do this and more than capable of doing it.

Pages